Dune Author's Son Gives Verdict on Villeneuve's Adaptation

Dune Author's Son Gives Verdict on Villeneuve's Adaptation
Image credit: Warner Bros. Pictures



  • Dune is a highly anticipated live-action adaptation of Frank Herbert's 1965 science fiction novel.
  • The adaptation has a star-studded cast including Timothée Chalamet, Zendaya and Florence Pugh.
  • The son of Frank Herbert gets candid on the Villeneuve adaptation, and it seems he's more than pleased.

It's always a challenge to make an adaptation that will satisfy fans and critics, but you know what is even harder? To please the creator of the original material — or their family, in case the creator is no longer with us.

Well, looks like Denis Villeneuve managed to exactly that, as Brian Herbert, the son of Frank Herbert who wrote the 1965 science fiction novel Dune, praised Dune: Part Two.

Moreover, Herbert believes that Dune 2, apart from the first part, was the best film adaptation of the original novel. The first film in the franchise was made in 1984 by director David Lynch. Denis Villeneuve is responsible for the current film adaptations, while the budget for the second part is estimated to be about $190 million.

“I saw Dune: Part Two at a private studio screening, and it is gratifying to see my father's story told with such great care. When the new movie is combined with Dune: Part One it is by far the best film interpretation of Frank Herbert’s classic novel Dune that has ever been done”, Brian stated.

Nostalgia swept over fans as they reminisced about reading Frank Herbert's books and eagerly awaited the cinematic experience.

“It makes me indescribably happy you enjoy it like so many of us do. I’m reading your prequel novels right now and they are breathtakingly captivating, just like your father’s writing. Thank you for carrying on his legacy”, X user csmiclatte said.

They expressed confidence in Villeneuve’s vision of the Dune as well:

"Never doubt Denis Villeneuve, he doesn't miss", X user ZoieNolan said.

On March 1, the premiere of the second part of “Dune 2” directed by Denis Villeneuve will take place, but the embargo on the publication of reviews is already lifted.

And critics overwhelmingly greeted the film with rave reviews — the rating of the second part on Rotten Tomatoes is higher than that of the first part (97% and 83% accordingly).

The movie is lauded by critics for its ability to “capture the bleakness and tragedy” inherent in Frank Herbert's novel. The film's script is commended for its handling of character complexities and its skillful expansion of the Dune universe, with some of the critics stating that Herbert himself would be proud of the adaptation's depth.

Villeneuve's direction is praised for tapping into the emotional and sociopolitical potential of the source material. However, some reviewers note a shift in tone from the restrained elegance of the first film to a more blockbuster-oriented experience in the sequel.