10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb
Image credit: Netflix

An absurd comedy starring Jesse Eisenberg, a thriller with Girls star, and a joint project of Olivia Cooke and Anya Taylor-Joy.

Netflix regularly delights viewers with new releases, but some worthy movies remain unnoticed in its huge library.

We've recalled ten such projects that have been unfairly overlooked but are definitely worth your time.

10. 'Body Cam', 2020

IMDb Score: 5.3/10

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb - image 1

Policewoman Renee is back on the job after an eight-month suspension. During her last arrest, she had a hard time holding back after witnessing the death of a child in a neighbor's pool.

She is assigned a rookie partner as an additional responsibility. On their first patrol on the outskirts of Los Angeles, they find the body of Renee's former partner, Kevin, who is crucified on a gate with a disfigured face. The murder clearly has a mystical nature.

9. 'Hold the Dark', 2018

IMDb Score: 5.7/10

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb - image 2

In a small Alaskan village, a child goes missing. The mother realizes the child is most likely already dead but still hires a naturalist hunter to track down a pack of wolves that often steal unattended children – she wants to take revenge. The hunter agrees but is immediately warned that he is about to encounter pure evil.

Hold the Dark is a film by Jeremy Saulnier, one of the best directors of violent thrillers. His latest movie, Rebel Ridge, was also released on Netflix and received rave reviews from critics and viewers.

8. 'Cam', 2018

IMDb Score: 5.9/10

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb - image 3

Camgirl Alice will do anything to become one of the top 50 models on the website. At one point, instead of her usual flirting, she stages a brutal suicide.

Alice's popularity grows rapidly, but she can't enjoy her first major success. Her account is hacked, and the support service refuses to help her.

Her anger quickly turns to shock when she notices that streams are continuing from her hacked account. It turns out that a girl who looks exactly like Alice is behind it.

7. 'The Perfection', 2018

IMDb Score: 6.2/10

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb - image 4

This under-the-radar, violent thriller, starring Girls actress Allison Williams, tells about rivalry and abuse.

Williams plays Charlotte, a cellist who is forced to drop out of the academy because of her dying mother. A few years later, she decides to resume her musical career, but another talented performer, Lizzie, has already taken her place.

A former teacher gives Charlotte a chance and agrees to take her on a big tour of China. There, she plans to eliminate her competitor and become the star of the academy again.

6. 'Villains', 2019

IMDb Score: 6.2/10

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb - image 5

An aspiring duo of criminals rob a gas station and break into a peaceful-looking house on a country road. They find a girl chained in the basement and soon the owners return – a couple of smiling, middle-aged psychopaths.

Initially, Villains appears to be heading in the direction of a thriller similar to Don't Breathe, but it leans more toward a black comedy about love.

5. 'The Souvenir', 2019

IMDb Score: 6.4/10

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb - image 6

A shy film student finds her passion for directing while navigating a romance with a charming but unreliable man.

Struggling to break free from her mother's protectiveness, she worries her friends as she falls deeper into a tense, emotionally charged relationship that threatens to destroy her dreams.

Director Joanna Hogg paints a deeply personal portrait of an artist as a young woman, combining passionate emotion and exquisite aesthetics to tell a heartfelt story of coming of age and first love.

4. 'The Art of Self-Defence', 2019

IMDb Score: 6.6/10

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb - image 7

The Art of Self-Defense is one of the funniest absurd comedies in recent years, starring Jesse Eisenberg.

Casey, a lonely accountant, goes out at night to buy dog food but is robbed by a biker gang. After spending several days in the hospital, he decides to buy a gun and enroll in a karate class. There, he falls under the influence of a charismatic sensei who teaches students the basics of self-defense.

3. 'Thoroughbreds', 2017

IMDb Score: 6.6/10

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb - image 8

The plot centers on longtime friends Amanda and Lily, who reunite after being apart for a long time. Amanda is unable to experience emotions, while Lily is overly emotional. Amanda notices Lily's stepfather's aggressive behavior, and the two friends decide to get rid of him as soon as possible.

The movie's greatest strength lies in the on-screen chemistry between Olivia Cooke and Anya Taylor-Joy, who play two characters that are complete opposites.

2. 'The Dig', 2021

IMDb Score: 7.1/10

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb - image 9

This unexpectedly subtle and metaphorical Netflix drama went unnoticed by most viewers. The plot centers on a wealthy widow who hires an archaeologist because she believes there are ancient relics on her property.

Together, they begin a dig. However, the historic discovery echoes too much of Britain's past and its uncertain future on the eve of World War II.

1. 'Divines', 2016

IMDb Score: 7.3/10

10 Criminally Underrated Netflix Movies You Probably Missed in 2025, Ranked by IMDb - image 10

Dounia and Maimouna are two 15-year-old friends from the Parisian suburbs who get involved in the local drug trade. They convince each other that they're doing it for money and success. However, beyond their calculations, each girl has a dream.

Maimouna wants to escape her deeply Orthodox family, while Dounia wants to leave the slums and her alcoholic mother behind.

🧡
😁
👏
🤔
😡
Crush of the day
Jeremy Allen White - Crush of the day
Jeremy Allen White From: The Bear

We're already in our "yes chef" mode.

or
Hot (53%) Not (47%)