10 Justin Hartley’s Best Movies and Shows to Watch After Tracker Season 2

CBS’ hit action drama Tracker has just wrapped its second season up with yet another major cliffhanger promising even more chaos for Justin Hartley’s Colter Shaw and his family.

Now that there’s an even bigger chance for Colter to get distracted from his job duties, the series will likely be back sooner than many thought, with the third season possibly hitting screens already this fall.

In case you’re already missing Justin Hartley’s character just days after the second season’s finale, here are some of the actor’s other works that might be just as worthy as Tracker.

‘The Noel Diary’ (2022)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, The Noel Diary holds scores of 73% and 64% from critics and viewers
• On IMDb, the movie is rated 6.2/10

Netflix’s Christmas romcom stars Justin Hartley in one of the leading roles, following best-selling author Jake Turner who returns home for Christmas to arrange his estranged mother’s estate, but instead discovers a diary full of shocking revelations.

Soon enough Jake finds a companion, a young woman with whom he will confront his own past and see what’s in store for his future.

‘The Exchange’ (2021)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, The Exchange keeps scores of 65% and 71% from critics and audiences
• On IMDb, the movie rates 5.7/10

In Dan Mazer’s sports comedy drama, Hartley takes on a leading role of Gary Rothbauer, a school gym teacher who quickly befriends Stéphane, an outgoing exchange program student from France sent to a Canadian town after another student’s request.

‘Jexi’ (2019)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, Jexi has scores of 23% and 71% from critics and viewers
• On IMDb, the movie’s rating is 6/10

In the Adam DeVine-led romantic comedy, Hartley portrays Brody, an ex-fiancé of Cate who seeks ways to start a relationship with DeVine’s Phil. In the meantime, the latter tries to get rid of his new virtual assistant called Jexi who has become just a little bit too controlling and self-aware.

‘Little’ (2019)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, Little holds scores of 46% and 63% from critics and audiences
• On IMDb, the movie is rated 5.6/10

In the Regina Hall-led fantasy comedy Hartley takes on a supporting role.

The movie primarily follows Jordan, an oppressive tech mogul who turns her assistant April’s life into a nightmare on a daily basis.

However, when Jordan is magically transformed into a 13-year-old version of herself on the eve of a very important presentation, the only person she can rely on is April.

‘This Is Us’ (2016 — 2022)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, This Is Us keeps scores of 94% and 81% from critics and viewers
• On IMDb, the show is rated 8.7/10

In NBC’s hit family drama, Hartley starred as Kevin Pearson, the eldest of the Pearson triplets and an initially self-absorbed and estranged actor who eventually gets a significant growth, overcoming major struggles like addiction and complicated family relationships.

“He's misunderstood, but maybe kind of an a--hole, you know. So, so you just, you sit there and you go, Man, I wish I could help this guy, but you just can’t”, the actor described his character in an interview with Entertainment Weekly back in 2024.

‘Smallville’ (2001 — 2011)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, Smallville has scores of 78% and 71% from critics and audiences
• On IMDb, the series is rated 7.5/10

Based on DC Comics’ character Superman, the superhero show sees Hartley as Oliver Queen, aka Green Arrow, the CEO of Queen Industries and leader of a small group of superheroes called Justice League.

Initially introduced as a recurring character, Oliver Queen becomes a regular in Smallville’s season 8.

Hartley’s portrayal of Green Arrow eventually boosted the character’s popularity and even paved the way for other TV adaptations with the character as one of the leads.

‘Emily Owens, M.D.’ (2012 — 2013)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, Emily Owens, M.D. keeps scores of 33% and 71% from critics and viewers
• On IMDb, the show’s rating is 7.5/10

In The CW’s medical drama Justin Hartley portrays Will Collins, a charming surgical intern at Denver Memorial Hospital.

Will is introduced as Emily Owens’ medical school friend who remains convinced that she’s in love with him.

‘Cold Case’ (2003 — 2010)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, Cold Case has a score of 95% from audiences
• On IMDb, the show rates 7.6/10

The police procedural drama starred Hartley in a guest role as Mike Delaney, a college student at Powell University who was murdered on the night of his graduation in 1982.

The further investigation delves into Mike’s personality, revealing the horrifying truth about him and the deeds that ultimately led to his death.

‘Chuck’ (2007 — 2012)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, Chuck holds scores of 90% and 92% from critics and viewers
• On IMDb, the show’s rating is 8.2/10

In the Zachary Levy-led comedy spy drama’s season 5, Hartley takes on a guest role of Wesley Sneijder, the kidnapped brother of Karl Sneijder, the president and CEO of the diamond giant Natal Jewelers.

The episode titled "Chuck Versus the Bearded Bandit" delves into the characters’ attempt to rescue Wesley, highlighting the challenges of their spy mission.

‘Hart of Dixie’ (2011 — 2015)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, Hart of Dixie holds scores of 81% and 88% from critics and audiences
• On IMDb, the series is rated 7.7/10

In The CW’s comedy drama series, Hartley portrays Jesse Kinsella, the older brother of Wade Kinsella, one of the show's main characters.

Jesse’s return to town causes even more tension in his complicated relationship with Wade, especially since Jesse also develops romantic feelings for Dr. Zoe Hart.