8 Best Horror TV Series to Binge if You Liked 'Widow's Bay', Ranked by Rotten Tomatoes

Widow's Bay is a rare TV series that successfully combines supernatural horror, dark humor, and the atmosphere of a small coastal town where everyone harbors a terrible secret.

If you've watched all the available episodes and are craving more strange rituals, sinister secrets, and cozy terror that's both frightening and captivating, this list is for you.

8. 'Grotesquerie', 2024

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 75%

Detective Lois investigates a series of grisly murders with religious overtones. Her family life is in turmoil: a month ago, her husband was admitted to the intensive care unit and remains hospitalized, meanwhile, her daughter suffers from an eating disorder and barely leaves the house.

Hoping to escape her domestic problems, Lois throws herself into searching for the killer. One day, Megan, a nun and journalist, unexpectedly joins the case, convinced that the killer is connected to the local Christian community.

Megan isn't your typical nun – she loves fast food and stories about serial killers and has a crush on the young pastor, Charlie.

7. '1899', 2022

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 77%

1899, the Kerberos is sailing from London to New York. The crew and passengers hail from different social classes, countries, and nationalities, and each person has a purpose for being on board.

Among them is neurologist Maura, who is following a letter from her brother suggesting they meet in New York. However, she suspects that her brother never made it to the New World.

The captain of the Kerberos, Eyk, receives a distress signal from the Prometheus, an infamous vessel that disappeared several months earlier in the Atlantic Ocean. Captain Eyk decides to change course, although it seems there is no one left to save.

6. 'The OA', 2016-2019

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 84%

After seven years away, Prairie Johnson returns to her adoptive parents, who remember her as being blind. She can now see, but that's not the only oddity that surprised her parents.

Upon her return, she claimed her name was OA and began speaking in riddles, even to the puzzled investigators. Specifically, she revealed that several people had been in the place where she'd been all these years, all of whom had been lost and died countless times.

She constantly records cryptic messages for someone named Homer, saying that she misses him terribly and will definitely come for him. She turns to a high school student for help and asks him to gather five strangers at midnight in an abandoned house.

5. 'Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen', 2026

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 85%

Rachel travels to her fiancé Nicky's family estate to get married. The family members she meets include a depressed mother-in-law, a taciturn father-in-law, a foul-tempered brother-in-law, his mysterious wife, and an overly active sister-in-law.

Throughout her journey, Rachel is haunted by ominous signs – a dead animal, an abandoned child, and a truck veering into oncoming traffic. Everything seems to indicate that something bad is about to happen.

At a roadside cafe, a sinister old man asks Rachel if she's sure about her choice. At her fiancé's house, she is met with nothing but coldness and chaos, the family members look down on her and are clearly hiding something.

4. 'Midnight Mass', 2021

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 87%

Every night, Riley has the same dream: a calm lake and a solitary boat at dawn. This deceptively serene image is shattered by the horror of waking up to find neither a living person nor a corpse before him, but rather a ghostly body – the spirit of a young woman.

After a heavily intoxicated young man drove the life out of a girl at full speed, Riley decided that God had abandoned him or didn't exist at all.

After receiving an early release, Riley returns to his native island, where Sunday service is the highlight of the few remaining locals' lives.

3. 'The Fall of the House of Usher', 2023

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 91%

Roderick Usher, along with his sister Madeline, is a pharmaceutical magnate who built an empire by producing dangerous painkillers. For years, federal prosecutor Auguste has been trying unsuccessfully to imprison them, but keeps losing to their family lawyer.

Everything changes when Roderick's children begin dying one after another. After the last one dies tragically, Auguste receives an invitation.

If he visits the dilapidated home of the Usher twins, he will learn the truth about their crimes, receive a confession, and discover what happened to Roderick's children.

2. 'The Haunting of Hill House', 2018

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 93%

In 1992, the Crain family – consisting of a mother, father, and five children – moved into the massive mansion of the late Hills, intending to renovate and sell it for a higher price in order to build their own home.

Over time, the family became distant from one another, and each survivor developed personal problems and traumas from their brief stay in the haunted house.

Things continued this way until the suicide of their youngest sister brought the children and their reclusive father together to confront what had tormented them all these years.

1. 'From', 2022-...

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 97%

The plot centers on a small, mysterious town located somewhere in Central America. The town lures in gullible travelers who are seeking a warm home and new friends.

Trapped, the travelers struggle to find a way out, but it's far from easy. As the sun sets, terrifying creatures emerge from their hiding places to hunt down the defenseless.