Concrete proof that Joran van der Sloot has been lying all along
Netflix's Taken: Natalee Holloway sets two decades of van der Sloot's stories against the footage. The footage wins every time.
Taken: Natalee Holloway opened at No. 1 on Netflix's English TV list for November 2–8 with 12.9 million views, and the reason to watch isn't the mystery. Joran van der Sloot confessed in 2023. The reason to watch is that the series lines up nearly 20 years of his stories against the hard evidence, and you get to watch each one collapse.
Former Aruban deputy police chief Gerold Dompig estimates van der Sloot changed his story about 40 times. Here are the greatest hits.
The stories
- June 2005, the hotel: He told investigators he and the Kalpoe brothers dropped Natalee at her Holiday Inn around 2 a.m. According to an FBI affidavit, the hotel's surveillance footage showed she never came back. He later admitted on TV that the three of them had agreed to lie.
- 2005–2008, the beach: The revised version had him alone with her on a beach near the Marriott, where he says he left her.
- 2008, the hidden camera: Dutch crime reporter Peter R. de Vries aired footage of van der Sloot telling a friend that Natalee died and that someone dumped her body at sea. Van der Sloot said that was a lie, too.
- 2008, the trafficker: In another version, he claimed he handed her over to a man who took her to Venezuela.
- 2010, the foundation: He told Beth Holloway's lawyer, John Q. Kelly, that Natalee's body was buried under the foundation of a house, with his father's help. It was invented, and he got paid for it.
- 2023, the confession: In his U.S. plea deal, he admitted he beat her, struck her with a cinder block and carried her body into the ocean.
One caveat, for completeness: Beth Holloway has given different accounts over the years of whether the Holiday Inn lobby cameras were working that night. It doesn't save him. He's the one who later admitted the hotel story was a lie.
Don't miss: 10 years later, Emilia Clarke's forgotten tearjerker blows up Netflix's top 10
The lie on tape
The series' real centerpiece is never-before-seen footage of the May 2010 FBI sting in Aruba. Van der Sloot had demanded $250,000 for the location of Natalee's remains. Beth's side paid a fraction of it, and Beth explains why she was fine with that:
"I thought, 'You know what? $25,000 is fine with me,' because I had a chance to get justice for Natalee."
— Beth Holloway, in Taken: Natalee Holloway, via Oxygen
On camera, Kelly asks him whether he's ready to be really specific about where Natalee is. Van der Sloot answers:
"I can't believe I'm doing it, but I'm ready."
— Joran van der Sloot, in the FBI sting footage
Then he gives them the house foundation story, takes the money and leaves for Peru. That's what this documentary has that no previous one did: not a confession, but the lie itself, recorded as it happens, with cash changing hands.
In 2005, hotel surveillance footage showed Natalee never came back the way he said. In 2010, hotel surveillance footage in Lima helped investigators identify him in Stephany Flores' murder.
Within weeks of the sting, Stephany Flores, 21, was dead in a Lima hotel room. Investigators recognized van der Sloot on the hotel's cameras, and he was arrested days later in Chile. Peru sentenced him to 28 years.
The last version
The 2023 confession is the only one he's given in exchange for something real: a plea deal that runs concurrently with his Peruvian sentence. Aruba can't charge him, because the statute of limitations has expired. Natalee's remains have never been found, so even this final account rests on his word alone, and Taken spends three episodes showing exactly what his word has been worth.
Previously we wrote: Rings of Power season 3 proves a mediocre show can't survive a two-year wait