Disney's banned Song of the South turns 80 — and its few viewers say you're missing nothing

Song of the South turns 80 on Thursday: a $2 million live-action-and-animation hybrid, premiered November 12, 1946, at Atlanta's Fox Theatre. It won an Oscar for "Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah" and an honorary one for James Baskett as Uncle Remus — the first Academy Award given to a Black male performer, for a premiere he wasn't allowed to attend because Atlanta's theaters were segregated.

Eighty years later it remains the most thoroughly buried film in the Disney vault: never released on US home video, never on Disney+, with Bob Iger telling shareholders in 2020 that even with a disclaimer it's "not appropriate in today's world." The racism charge is as old as the film — the NAACP's Walter White objected within days to its idyllic picture of plantation life, and Time predicted on release that it would land Disney "in hot water."

What the people who found a copy report

None of that is in dispute, and it's also not the whole story of why the vault stays shut. The film circulates anyway — overseas VHS rips, Spanish and Italian discs — and the testimony of people who actually watched it keeps converging on the same anticlimax:

"The animated parts are lovely but the live action parts, questionable morals aside, are just so tedious and slow to get through. … Disney proudly stands by stuff that is three times as racist as anything in Song of the South"

— a commenter on r/boxoffice

The structure is the problem. The animated Br'er Rabbit sequences everyone remembers add up to roughly 25 minutes; the rest is a slow plantation melodrama in which a subplot about a boy's ruined dress eats whole reels. Another commenter pointed to video essayist Lindsay Ellis's reading: the real reason Disney wants the film dead is that it's dull and uninteresting to watch.

The legend is the asset

Here's the uncomfortable accounting for Disney. Locked away, Song of the South is a myth — the forbidden masterpiece-slash-atrocity, the thing YouTube essays and Reddit threads turn 80th birthdays into content about. Released with a scholarly disclaimer, it would be a two-hour film where audiences wait 20 minutes between cartoon sequences, and the myth would deflate on contact.

Don't miss: When Harry Met Sally's original ending has no New Year's Eve speech in it at all

Disney has run this experiment's control group already: the company spent decades defending Splash Mountain as drawing only on the animated sections, then rethemed it to The Princess and the Frog anyway. Even inside Disney, the only part of this film anyone fought to keep was those 25 animated minutes.

Disney's most notorious film enters the US public domain in 2042. The company has 16 years left of the legend outliving the movie.

So if you've spent your life wanting to see the one Disney film you're not allowed to see — the honest birthday message from the people who found it is that the ban is doing you a favor. The racism is real, the history is worth knowing, Baskett deserved better than both his premiere and his material. The movie, meanwhile, is the rare scandal that would be demoted by being watched.

Previously we wrote: Elsinore is based on a true story that starts when Daniel Day-Lewis walked off Hamlet mid-run