Dune: Part Three bent the book to fit Anya Taylor-Joy — I'm not sure it was worth it

The new wave of Dune: Part Three images arrived on October 15 as part of Empire's cover story on the December 18 finale, and the shot that set off r/movies wasn't Chalamet or Zendaya. It was Anya Taylor-Joy as Alia Atreides — a character who, by the film's own math, is a teenager.

The fan objection is blunt, and the thread isn't hiding it:

"She looks 30 in this image... a far cry from child Alia, no matter how they try to twist it."

— a commenter on r/movies

Taylor-Joy is 33. In Frank Herbert's Dune Messiah, the gap between books is 12 years; Villeneuve's film jumps 17. Since the movie's Alia was still unborn at the end of Part Two, the stretched timeline puts her at sixteen or seventeen — and another commenter in the thread spelled out the suspicion that the arithmetic was reverse-engineered: "Read that the time jump between parts 2 & 3 was extended from 12 years to 17, to justify this casting. Even if she was born soon after the events of the second film, I'm not sure if she passes for 16-17."

Don't miss: 'It will be graded on a curve': Sorkin on whether The Social Reckoning is a sequel to The Social Network

What the change costs

I keep coming back to what Alia is for. In the book, she's unsettling precisely because an ancient consciousness lives inside a visibly young girl — the Fremen call her Abomination, and the horror is the mismatch. Cast a grown star, and the uncanny thing the character was built on quietly disappears; what's left is another powerful adult in a saga already full of them. Villeneuve has adapted ruthlessly before and been right, but this is the first change his Dune has made that reads as serving the casting rather than the story.

Alia's whole book identity is an adult mind trapped in a child's body. The film's solution is to remove the child.

The counterargument is on the record, and it's not nothing. Taylor-Joy already played Alia in the Part Two vision cameo, so this casting was locked before any timeline was stretched. Chalamet, at the IMAX fan event in July, said of her performance: "She's actually terrifying and amazing," adding that "the first day Anya stepped on set, just visually, it was breathtaking." Taylor-Joy herself describes Alia as having "a very intense blessing/curse situation" whose anchor is "her love and devotion to her brother."

Terrifying is the right ambition for Alia, and if anyone can play a knife-edge teenager at 33, it's the woman who carried The Queen's Gambit. But Villeneuve's Dune earned its reputation by trusting the book's strangest ideas — and this time, on the strangest one of all, it blinked first. I'd love the finished film to prove the Reddit thread and me wrong on December 18, the same day Avengers: Doomsday opens opposite it.

Previously we wrote: Joe Russo picked Tom Holland as the last movie star — Beekeeper fans have a better answer