Even Rings of Power's best new character is secretly Gollum

Even Rings of Power's best new character is secretly Gollum
Image credit: Legion Media

Season 3 finally has a character worth caring about: Marnûkh, the orc who defects from Sauron. Look at his arc for ten seconds and you'll see whose it is.

I'll give The Rings of Power this: season 3 has a genuinely good new character, and nobody saw it coming. Marnûkh, played by Adam Young, is an orc in Sauron's forge whom the Dark Lord sends to hunt down surviving Elven-smiths. He immediately betrays his boss and carries the information to the Dwarves and Elves. He's funny, twitchy and untrustworthy, and he's the first thing in three seasons people bring up without being asked. Critics agree: But Why Tho called the "orc with an arc" an unexpected delight.

Then you watch him for a few more scenes and realize you've seen this movie. Twice, actually: The Two Towers and The Return of the King.

The beat sheet

Line Marnûkh's first four episodes up against Peter Jackson's Gollum and the template is right there:

  • The master: Gollum belongs to the Ring and, through it, to Sauron. Marnûkh is Sauron's orc, standing in the forge during the premiere's ring test.
  • The diet: Gollum eats raw fish while the hobbits look away. Marnûkh eats bugs, though, as AV Club notes, "not in front of Galadriel."
  • The guide: Gollum leads Frodo and Sam through enemy country. AV Club's recap of episodes 1–4 says Marnûkh "becomes Sméagol to Galadriel and Arondir's Frodo and Sam" on the road to Gundabad.
  • The question: Is he good now? Both characters run on the same suspense, and episode 4 gives Marnûkh a double-turn straight out of Gollum's playbook.

Showrunner Patrick McKay calls the trio a "buddy-frenemy story." It's a great dynamic. It was also a great dynamic in 2002.

"He's bad and he eats bugs, but then he helps, so maybe he's good!"

— a commenter on r/television, on Marnûkh

Three seasons and roughly a billion dollars in, the character everyone finally agrees on eats things raw, guides two heroes through enemy land and might be good. Peter Jackson had that in The Two Towers.

It's the whole season

Marnûkh isn't an isolated case. Season 3 is full of film callbacks: heroes hiding from Nazgûl behind a tree, an Indiana Jones-style grab for Gandalf's hat as if the hat were a sacred relic, a not-quite Frodo-Sam-Gollum trio out on the road. Every one of them is the show reminding you of a better version of itself.

Elijah Wood, Sean Astin and Andy Serkis as Frodo, Sam and Gollum in The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (2002). AV Club says Marnûkh becomes Sméagol to Galadriel and Arondir's Frodo and Sam
Elijah Wood, Sean Astin and Andy Serkis as Frodo, Sam and Gollum in The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (2002). AV Club says Marnûkh becomes Sméagol to Galadriel and Arondir's Frodo and Sam. Image credit: Legion Media

There's a structural reason for it. Amazon bought The Lord of the Rings and its appendices, not The Silmarillion, so the Second Age it's adapting mostly exists as timelines and footnotes. The writers have to invent almost everything between the big canonical events. When they need something to land with a mass audience, the fastest route is whatever that audience already loves, and what it loves is Jackson.

Don't miss: Rings of Power season 3 proves a mediocre show can't survive a two-year wait

The cover version problem

Here's the frustrating part: the borrowing works. Gollum is one of the best character designs in modern fantasy, a creature whose loyalty is the whole suspense. Put that in an orc, cast a performer who's clearly having a blast, and you get the season's best scenes. It's also telling that the show's previous fan favorite was another orc, Adar. Its best instincts keep coming from the side Tolkien wrote as faceless.

But "best new character" is supposed to be the show's own win. Three seasons in, its biggest hit is a cover of the most famous performance in the franchise. Episodes 5 and 6 drop November 18. Marnûkh has two weeks to do something Gollum never did. Otherwise he's Andy Serkis' understudy in green makeup.

Previously we wrote: Fourth Wing's ending explained: the War Games were never a test