How Many Seasons Are There in ‘American Idol’ & Which Is the Best One?
From Kelly Clarkson to the latest sensation, there are many reasons why picking the best American Idol season is difficult. But we're here to help you find your binge-worthy starting point!
Since its debut in 2002, American Idol has continued to bring in new viewers while maintaining its loyal fan base.
Through its 23-year run, the show has aired 23 seasons, with the 24th expected to premiere in spring 2026.
Although the show has undergone major changes over the years, one thing has remained consistent: American Idol remains a great opportunity for up-and-coming musicians. But which season deserves the crown as the absolute best? That's where things get tricky.
Which Season of ‘American Idol’ Is the Best One?
Picking the best American Idol season really depends on your taste. But if you're new to the show and wondering where to start, we've got some ideas.
If you're someone who trusts IMDb ratings, you'll find that the later seasons tend to score higher. However, if you're more inclined to trust the fanbase, die-hard fans often argue that seasons 1–5 embody the original spirit that made the show so popular in the first place.
‘American Idol’ Fans on Where to Start
“For me, it has to be season 1. The talent was nowhere as good as later seasons because these were just kids with little to no experience and stars in their eyes,” Redditor Justadropinthesea wrote.
“Seaons 4 and 5 were my favorite, but I missed the first three. Up until seasons 7 and 8 would be best to watch,” another fan, TakenAccountName37 on Reddit recommended.
“1, 2, 4, 7, 8, 9, 10, and 11. These are the best talent seasons, IMO, and include the biggest stars to actually come out of the show. The only other season I was considering is 3. The best seasons are the ones with the original judges, particularly through season 9, so you can't really go wrong with those if you ask me,” Redditor Atown0921 said.
