I keep seeing Rings of Power posts. I've never met a person who watches it

Four days before The Rings of Power returns for season 3, my feeds are wall-to-wall Middle-earth: promoted posts, teaser cuts, creature featurettes. What I can't find is the other thing a franchise this size is supposed to produce — people talking about it because they want to. No theories clogging my timelines, no lines quoted at me, not one person in my life who brings the show up unprompted.

This week r/television asked the question out loud: why does every Rings of Power post that reaches the front page look like corporate marketing? The answers from inside the fandom were bleaker than the question. One self-described massive Tolkien fan admitted to watching "out of obligation basically." Another summed up the community's experience in a line that deserves framing:

"we tried to have organic engagement but amazon wouldn't let us"

A billion dollars buys reach, not love

That gap is the story. Amazon paid $250 million for the rights before shooting a frame, spent a reported $465 million on season 1 alone, and the five-season commitment makes this the most expensive television series ever made — north of a billion dollars. That money visibly bought production value and, judging by my feeds, a marketing budget to match.

What it hasn't bought, five years in, is a cultural footprint. Season 2's audience halved against season 1 by its back half, and Amazon has managed reception closely since launch — in 2022 it introduced a 72-hour delay on user reviews for the show. House of the Dragon, airing the same seasons, split the internet into factions with nicknames. Rings of Power has not produced a meme, a discourse, or a catchphrase that escaped its own subreddit.

A billion dollars in, the show's most visible fan content is the advertising.

The obligation audience

The watch-out-of-obligation confession is the detail I keep coming back to, because it describes a specific kind of viewer: someone holding a seat out of loyalty to Tolkien, not to the show. That's an audience that erodes one season at a time and generates exactly zero evangelism while it lasts.

Don't miss: 'Who was begging for the romantasy angle on Tolkien?': Rings of Power just confirmed its love triangle

Amazon committed to five seasons up front, so season 3 will not live or die on buzz. But for anyone deciding whether to finally start the series, the signal is worth reading: when a show has been running for four years and the only people talking about it are the ones paid to, that silence is the review.

Previously we wrote: 'David B must have the best agent in Hollywood': the Rockford Files reboot proves it