New Friends recast imagines the sitcom made today, and Daniel Radcliffe is Chandler
Collider named Friends' famous diversity problem in its first paragraph. Then it cast the show.
Collider's "The Perfect 'Friends' Cast if the Sitcom Were Made Today", by Christine Persaud, opens by acknowledging two things: that Friends is known for its limited diversity, and that actors look younger now, so people in their 30s can play these parts. Then it delivers the six friends:
- Rachel: Sydney Sweeney
- Ross: Jesse Eisenberg
- Chandler: Daniel Radcliffe
- Monica: Anya Taylor-Joy
- Joey: Dave Franco
- Phoebe: Haley Lu Richardson
That's six white actors. Zendaya and Jenna Ortega are honorable mentions for Rachel, Tyler James Williams for Ross, and Ayo Edebiri and Chase Infiniti for Monica. The two actors of color who did make the main list are Suraj Sharma as Gunther and Isabela Merced as Janice: the guy behind the counter and the girlfriend everyone runs from.
Collider's "made today" Friends opens by noting the original's lack of diversity. Its six friends are all white, and Zendaya is an honorable mention.
The picks, honestly ranked
Chandler, Daniel Radcliffe. The headline pick, and the best one. Collider cites his comedic timing, his willingness to be silly, and sarcasm that could hide insecurity. Anyone who saw him play Weird Al knows he'll do anything for a bit. Correct.
Ross, Jesse Eisenberg. Anxious, awkward, smart: the casting writes itself. Collider says his youthful face could pass for early 30s. David Schwimmer was 27 when Friends premiered. Eisenberg is 43.

Rachel, Sydney Sweeney. Collider calls her "this generation's 'it' girl," which is true. It's also true that her last big pop-culture moment was the 2025 American Eagle "great jeans" campaign and the backlash that followed. Today's Rachel arrives with her own discourse cycle.
Monica, Anya Taylor-Joy. Collider sees her as the uptight neat-freak chef. Her best-known kitchen scene to date is leaving The Menu with a cheeseburger to go.
Joey, Dave Franco. "Handsome but goofy," says Collider. Fine. Joey is the one role where the original casting is basically the job description.
Don't miss: The heartbreaking reason the Friends cast refused to join Matthew Perry's Netflix doc
Phoebe, Haley Lu Richardson. Picked off The White Lotus. The guitar is doing a lot of work in this pitch.
Mike Hannigan, Paul Rudd. Collider's argument is that no one else could play him, which means the cast of Friends "made today" includes the man who played the part in 2002. He's 57.
And Gunther's honorable mention is Reba McEntire. No notes.
What a Friends made today actually needs
Fancasting is fun because it skips the real problem. A Friends made today doesn't need a 43-year-old Ross. It needs to explain how six people in their twenties hang out every day in a giant West Village apartment that Monica is illegally subletting from her grandmother at a rent-controlled price. Made today, the pilot ends with Monica getting evicted. Radcliffe can be Chandler in whatever's left.
Previously we wrote: Harry Potter fans still annoyed over terrible choice for Snape