One Marshals change Luke Grimes really struggled with
Luke Grimes has spent a season and a half as the face of a show that killed his on-screen wife between series. Now he's saying out loud what Yellowstone fans said back in March.
Luke Grimes told ScreenRant, in an interview Fox News picked up on November 15, that the hardest part of Marshals wasn't the badge, the procedural format or leaving the ranch. It was the empty chair.
"The thing I was most worried about doing 'Marshals' was doing it without Kelsey."
— Luke Grimes, to ScreenRant
He went further: "Like I just couldn't wrap my head around Kayce without Monica. That was the story." And then the line that sums up five seasons of Kayce Dutton better than any recap: "The rest of 'Yellowstone' was about people fighting over land," Grimes said, "and I just loved my wife."
That was the story
Grimes isn't exaggerating. Kayce's whole arc on Yellowstone was choosing Monica and their son Tate over the Dutton war, and the series finale literally ended with the three of them walking away from it. Marshals opened in March with Monica already dead of cancer, written out before episode one. The reasons that have surfaced since are scheduling (Kelsey Asbille was reportedly committed elsewhere) and rights: a March report cited by /Film said the off-screen death helped separate Marshals from Yellowstone, whose streaming rights sit with NBC. Asbille still hasn't said a word about it publicly.

So the lead actor, the fans and, per her "missed opportunity" comment over the summer, even Kelly Reilly over on Dutton Ranch are on the same page. The people who made the call are the ones who aren't.
Luke Grimes says he couldn't picture Kayce without Monica. Marshals went ahead with exactly that, and it became the No. 1 new series premiere of the broadcast season.
The ring is still on
Season 2, now airing Sundays on CBS, is building toward a romance between Kayce and fellow marshal Andrea Cruz (Ash Santos), and part of the audience is not having it. Grimes' answer to those fans is blunt:
"They're not wrong. They're meant to feel that way."
— Luke Grimes, to ScreenRant
He says he's "always loved a will-they, won't-they kind of a storyline," calls Kayce and Andrea "kindred souls," and likes that the show is letting them build "a really amazing friendship first." Fine. Then comes the detail that should worry Monica's fans more than any shipping war: Kayce is still wearing his wedding ring, and nobody has decided what happens to it.
Don't miss: Fans still can't forgive Marshals for killing off Yellowstone's Monica
"Spencer and I have talked about, like, when do I take it off?" Grimes said, referring to showrunner Spencer Hudnut. "Are we going to make this a thing or is it just going to not be there one day? So we're still trying to figure that out."
Monica's death happened off-screen. Whether her wedding ring gets a scene of its own is, per Grimes, still undecided.
The promise
To his credit, Grimes knows what the show owes her. Once he accepted that Monica's death would "open up all these new storylines," he said, the job became clear: "we just have to make sure we do honor that and don't try to skip over it or pretend it didn't happen."
That's the right instinct, and it's the exact thing Marshals didn't do the first time. The ring is the test. If it simply isn't on Kayce's hand one week, the show will have handled Monica's last trace the same way it handled her death, and her fans will notice before anyone in the writers' room does.
Previously we wrote: Cole Hauser spills the beans on what went wrong with Dutton Ranch