The Big Bang Theory's season 9 premiere was its first red flag before the downfall

The Big Bang Theory's season 9 premiere was its first red flag before the downfall
Image credit: Legion Media

"The Matrimonial Momentum" drew 18.2 million viewers. It also turned the show's central romance into a cautionary tale and set the template for its last four seasons.

SlashFilm's Nina Starner traces The Big Bang Theory's decline to one episode: "The Matrimonial Momentum," the season 9 premiere that aired September 21, 2015. She calls it one of the show's all-time worst. Screen Rant got there first, ranking it the worst episode of the entire series in 2019.

Eight seasons of will-they-won't-they ended like this. Leonard and Penny drive to Las Vegas to get married, and on the way Leonard confesses that he kissed another woman during a research trip to the North Sea two years earlier. Penny is hurt that he cheated and that he hid it. They get married anyway, at a chapel, with no friends or family there. The wedding night is a dud, and they go home to separate apartments. Meanwhile Sheldon, freshly dumped by Amy, briefly considers dating the woman Leonard kissed just to hurt Amy.

Leonard and Penny's first wedding had no guests. 18.2 million people watched it anyway.

What the episode broke

  • The romance: The show's longest arc paid off with a cheating confession in a car and a ceremony nobody they love attended.
  • The format: Once everyone was paired off, the ensemble comedy became a rotation of relationship problems. Starner's examples: a second Leonard and Penny wedding in the season 10 premiere, then Amy and Sheldon's wedding in the season 11 finale.
  • The men: Starner points out that most of the bad relationship behavior from season 9 on comes from the male characters. Howard plays as a manchild, and Sheldon's response to Amy wanting physical intimacy gets treated as a running joke.

The critics noticed at the time. The Globe and Mail's John Doyle reviewed season 9 by saying the show wasn't funny anymore, the jokes had gone stale, and it felt dated.

The ratings never noticed

The premiere drew 18.2 million live viewers. Four years later, the series finale drew 18.5 million and closed out the run as TV's top-rated comedy, with 279 episodes, the most ever for a multi-camera sitcom. By Nielsen's math, there was no downfall.

Kaley Cuoco and Johnny Galecki as Penny and Leonard in The Big Bang Theory (2007). Their Las Vegas wedding in the season 9 premiere drew 18.2 million viewers
Kaley Cuoco and Johnny Galecki as Penny and Leonard in The Big Bang Theory (2007). Their Las Vegas wedding in the season 9 premiere drew 18.2 million viewers. Image credit: Legion Media

That's exactly the problem. The decline was creative, not commercial. The Big Bang Theory got worse and stayed enormous at the same time, so nobody at CBS had a reason to change anything. Season 9's formula, couples in crisis and weddings as finales, ran unchallenged for four more years because it kept winning.

Don't miss: The only TBBT episode its own showrunner flat-out hates

Starner also argues the slide began earlier, when Amy and Bernadette joined the cast. Her own article notes that Simon Helberg disagrees and thinks they made the show better. He's right. The women weren't the problem. The problem was a show that decided its women existed mainly to be married to the guys, and then made those marriages the whole plot.

The show is still a hit on HBO Max, where season 9 starts one click after the season 8 finale. That might be the best place to stop.

Previously we wrote: Canceled TBBT storyline fans never got to see because of Kaley Cuoco's accident