This Richard Linklater Black Comedy Is Based on an Insane Crime That Divided an Entire Town
This movie did more than tell a story – it intervened in the judicial system.
The line between real-life tragedy and black comedy is sometimes hauntingly thin. The story of Bernie Tiede, who was both the most beloved citizen of Carthage, Texas, and a cold-blooded killer, is a perfect example of this.
Richard Linklater was captivated by this incredible and paradoxical story, which he turned into a black comedy titled Bernie in 2011, starring Jack Black.
What Is 'Bernie' About?
Bernie Tiede is an incredibly kind, pious, and outgoing funeral director and the life of the town. His polar opposite is Margie Nugent, a hated, wealthy, and cantankerous widow.
Despite their differences, Bernie's sincere concern melts Margie's heart, and they become inseparable friends. However, over time, their friendship turns toxic.
The movie explores how this unhealthy relationship led to an unimaginable crime that the entire town chose to understand and forgive.
The Real-Life Story of Bernie and Margie
Bernie Tiede lost his parents at a young age and dedicated his life to helping the bereaved by becoming a funeral director. He was beloved in Carthage for his boundless kindness and compassion.
Everything changed when he met 81-year-old millionaire Margie Nugent. After her husband died, Bernie became her only friend and companion. Ultimately, he became the manager of her fortune.
However, over time, Marge made his life miserable, demanding complete submission. Driven to despair, Bernie shot Margie in 1996, hid her body in a freezer, and spent nine months feigning her presence while spending her money on charity.
When the crime was discovered, public opinion sided with Bernie: everyone in Carthage believed that he was the victim of unbearable tyranny. He was sentenced to life in prison only because the trial was moved to another city.
Richard Linklater's Movie Drew Attention to the Case, Leading to Its Reexamination
The 2011 release of the movie revived interest in the forgotten case. Bernie's lawyer initiated a retrial, citing mitigating circumstances that were not considered during the original trial, such as Margie's emotional abuse and Bernie's childhood trauma.
During the retrial, Linklater personally bailed Bernie out and housed him in his garage. Although the conviction was upheld in 2016, the case generated significant resonance.
In 2029, Tiede will be eligible for parole, bringing one of the strangest crime sagas of modern times to a close.
What Did Critics & Viewers Think of 'Bernie'?
-
Bernie has 88% from critics and 73% from viewers on Rotten Tomatoes.
-
On IMDb, the movie has a score of 6.8/10.
-
On Letterboxd, Bernie scored 3.5/5.0.
Where to Watch 'Bernie'?
Bernie is available to stream on Amazon Prime Video.
