Why Fans Prefer Batman Over Superman — And How James Gunn’s New DCU Flip Changes Everything

What do people really prefer — Batman or Superman? Despite Batman’s dark, brooding nature, he’s often the fan favorite. Why? Because he’s human. Vulnerable. He can be beaten. James Gunn, the mastermind behind the DC Universe reboot, gets it — and that’s exactly why the new Superman is set to change dramatically.

Speaking with Rolling Stone, Gunn opened up about his bold vision: Superman will still be powerful, but he won’t be the unstoppable god-figure fans might expect. Gunn took cues from Batman’s appeal — a hero who feels real because he faces pain and defeat. "A lot of people like Batman better because he can actually be beat" Gunn said. "So we have a Superman that can be beat."

He didn’t want another invincible hero who punches planets into dust or wins fights just by being a cosmic powerhouse.

"I see those online debates — 'Who would win, Homelander or Superman or whoever?"' Gunn said bluntly. "That’s the stupidest conversation. I could just create 'God Man' who destroys everything with a wink, and that’s no fun."

Instead, Gunn aims to balance his new DC Universe. With heroes like Guy Gardner’s Green Lantern packing serious punch, what’s a girl with wings supposed to do if Superman is all-powerful? The answer: Superman is getting scaled back. Less planet-punching, more relatable. Vulnerable, even.

This fresh take means the Man of Steel won’t just be a symbol of raw power, but a hero with real stakes — one who can lose, struggle, and grow. And in that very human struggle, audiences might just find a Superman they can truly root for.

So buckle up — the DCU’s new Superman isn’t your father’s superhero. He’s flawed, he’s fierce, and he’s ready to prove that even legends can be vulnerable.