Why would Enid tell Bertha Russell about the President's dinner? The Gilded Age fans smell a backfire
Season 4's social war opened with Bertha's former lady's maid informing her she isn't invited to dine with the President. Fans give the President two episodes before he's eating at Bertha's table.
In "You Won't Hear Me Beg," this week's episode of The Gilded Age, Enid Winterton corners Bertha Russell with the season's juiciest piece of information: the President is coming to dinner at the van Rhijns' — the visit Enid herself is sponsoring — and Bertha is not on the guest list. Enid delivers this personally, ahead of time, with relish.
Remember who Enid is. Kelley Curran's character entered this show as Turner, Bertha's own lady's maid, before marrying up into the Winterton fortune and getting promoted, this season, to full-time rival. Nobody in New York has watched Bertha's methods from closer range — the gloat is spectacularly unwise coming from her, and fans called it instantly:
"I think Enid was gloating. Her mother-in-law, just across the road, the president, you're not invited... it felt very gloaty. But it's going to backfire and Bertha will steal the dinner."
— a commenter on r/thegildedage
The Duke precedent
This exact play has been run before, against this exact woman, and Enid was there when it happened. In season 2, the Duke of Buckingham was the Wintertons' trophy guest — until Bertha poached him, built her opera-war victory around him, and eventually turned him into her son-in-law. A second commenter did not let that history slide:
"She couldn't resist the delicious gloating… but it seems shockingly amateurish to tell her ahead of time…girl that woman stole your Duke why don't you think she can't steal your President?!!"
— a commenter on r/thegildedage
The ledger on this rivalry already has one entry, and it's in Bertha's column.
Bertha took a Duke off Enid's dinner table in season 2 and married him into the family. Enid just told her where the President will be eating.
Why the telling is the gift
Bertha Russell's entire career runs on one fuel: being told a door is closed. Mrs. Astor told her society was closed, so she built a rival opera house. The old families told her a Duke was above her, so she bought one.
The pattern is so established that Julian Fellowes barely hides the machinery anymore. When an old-money character smugly announces an exclusion in episode 2, they are loading the season's trophy into Bertha's hands.
Don't miss: Who are the LGBT characters in The Gilded Age? One of them has a president in his family tree
That's my read of where this season is headed: the show is engineering Bertha's biggest social triumph yet, and it's built the oldest way it knows — old money handing her the weapon personally. Gladys's delivery has brought Bertha back to New York, George is wounded and wobbling but home, and a sitting President is three hundred feet from her drawing room. Enid didn't protect her dinner by taunting Bertha with it. She put it on the menu.
Previously we wrote: Why is Rivals, the horniest period drama on TV, the one Disney+ won't promote?