Why X-Files episode Home was banned from syndication: Fox ordered that "those characters never appear on television again"

"Home" aired on October 11, 1996 — season 4, episode 2 — and then, effectively, never again. Written by Glen Morgan and James Wong and directed by Kim Manners, the hour sent Mulder and Scully to a postcard Pennsylvania town to investigate a deformed infant buried in a field, and found the Peacocks: three inbred brothers and the limbless mother they keep on a rolling cart under the bed.

It became the first episode of the series to open with a viewer discretion warning and the only one in eleven seasons to carry a TV-MA rating. Fox pulled it from repeats after the single broadcast — the only episode in the show's history never rerun in its normal rotation.

How far the ban actually went

The network didn't just decline to re-air an episode; it blacklisted fictional characters. Years later, when Morgan and Wong were running season 2 of Millennium, Chris Carter's sister show, they pitched bringing the surviving Peacocks back. The idea reportedly cleared the initial conversations — until the phone rang.

"Those characters never appear on television again."

— Fox, in a phone call, as recalled by Glen Morgan in a New York Times oral history

So they dumped it. The Peacocks never returned on The X-Files or Millennium, and the closest thing to a sequel is the title of Morgan's 2016 revival episode, "Home Again" — a wink, not a continuation. Carter himself got the executive treatment on day one, telling The Hollywood Reporter this year that the morning after broadcast was loud:

"I got a screaming call from an executive the next day."

— Chris Carter, to The Hollywood Reporter

By his account, the message was the same: it aired once, it would never air again, they had gone too far.

Don't miss: The Terror: Devil in Silver cast and release date: Dan Stevens meets the Devil himself — with Ridley Scott producing

The ban became the ad campaign

Here's the part Fox would probably rather not have in the retrospectives. The network held the line for exactly three years, then re-aired "Home" once, as a Halloween 1999 stunt — and promoted its own censorship. The TV Guide ad, reprinted by the NYT, sold it as "an episode so controversial, it's been banned from television for three years."

After that, the episode quietly slipped back into circulation through syndication on FX, the sister cable network the original ban conveniently didn't cover, and today it streams on Hulu with the rest of the series. A few footnotes that explain the queasy power of the hour:

• The soundtrack problem: Johnny Mathis declined to license his recording of "Wonderful! Wonderful!" after learning what scene it would play under, so the Peacocks' night drive is scored by a soundalike cover — which somehow makes it worse.
• The title: Morgan has said the episode is called "Home" because he and Wong were returning home to the show after time away, and the idea curdled from there — one person's safety and comfort being another's nightmare.
• The intent: Wong's position has never wavered; they set out to make a terrifying hour of television, were surprised the first outraged calls came from executives rather than viewers, and he remains proud of it.

Fox banned the episode for three years, then bought a full-page ad to brag about the ban.

Morgan's own verdict on the whole affair is the most honest one: he has said he doesn't know if anyone would remember "Home" if it hadn't been banned. Thirty years on, it tops every "scariest episodes ever" list, and the suits who tried to bury it did most of the marketing.

Previously we wrote: Will Carrie be renewed for season 2? Mike Flanagan says true Stephen King fans already know where the series goes — reviews spotted his clue