I Play Rocky takes on The Hunger Games. What's the box office prediction?

I Play Rocky takes on The Hunger Games. What's the box office prediction?
Image credit: Legion Media

A $25 million movie about an underdog steps into the ring with a franchise champion. Anyone who's seen the original knows the fight isn't really about winning.

This Friday, November 20, one day before the 50th anniversary of Rocky, Peter Farrelly's I Play Rocky finally goes wide. It couldn't have picked a more fitting opponent. The same day, Lionsgate opens The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, the kind of heavyweight that usually gets the whole weekend to itself.

If this sounds familiar, it should. An unknown with a great story gets a shot at the champ almost by accident. The box office version of that matchup has a pretty clear favorite. The interesting question is the one Rocky Balboa asked himself in 1976: what does going the distance look like?

The champion: Sunrise on the Reaping

Let's be honest about the weight classes. Trackers have Sunrise on the Reaping opening somewhere around $105–120 million domestically, with a few bullish estimates going past $130 million and early long-range forecasts as low as $55–65 million. Box office analyst Todd Thatcher puts it at $122.5 million.

Even the cautious numbers would be a huge jump for the franchise. The previous prequel, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, debuted to just $44 million in 2023. Thatcher's reasoning is simple: this one has "more of a connection to the original quadrilogy," which in practice means Haymitch, the 50th Hunger Games and a story fans already know ends in heartbreak.

When the champ is tracking north of $100 million, the challenger isn't fighting for first place. He's fighting to still be standing in round 15.

And this challenger has been quietly training for two weeks already.

The challenger: I Play Rocky

Here's where it gets fun. I Play Rocky isn't coming in cold. It opened on seven screens on November 6 and grossed about $345,000, roughly $49,300 per screen. By mid-November it had passed $1.8 million worldwide before going wide anywhere in the US, including more than $800,000 from its UK opening.

Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping (2026). The prequel opens on the same day as I Play Rocky.
Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping (2026). The prequel opens on the same day as I Play Rocky. Image credit: Legion Media

The forecasts for Friday are healthy:

  • Todd Thatcher: $16.4 million, good for second place behind Sunrise on the Reaping.
  • World of Reel: $20 million or more is "very much on the table," citing strong presales, if Amazon MGM gets the film into 2,500+ locations.

The theater count is the big unknown. The Hunger Games is going to eat up a lot of screens, and World of Reel's advice to Amazon is blunt: "go as wide as possible on this one. Nothing to lose, especially with the film's budget only being $25M."

Our call

The champ wins the weekend. Sunrise on the Reaping takes first with something in the $110–125 million range, which is roughly where the tracking keeps settling.

Don't miss: Does I Play Rocky have an end credits scene? Don't leave until Johnny Carson has had his say

I Play Rocky lands in second with a mid-to-high teens opening, roughly $16–20 million, and the upside depends entirely on how many theaters Amazon books. Thatcher also expects it to be "more of a slow burn," with word-of-mouth that "indicates it should be a major crowd pleaser." The calendar agrees: next week is Thanksgiving, the exact moment when families go looking for a sincere old-school underdog story.

Rocky didn't beat Apollo Creed. He went the distance, and that was enough to launch a franchise. I Play Rocky doesn't need to beat Katniss's mentor either.

In fact, a close look at the money suggests second place might be the best possible result.

Why second place is a win here

Do the math on what Amazon MGM actually needs. With a $25 million budget, an opening in the high teens would put a serious dent in I Play Rocky's costs in a single weekend, with Thanksgiving still ahead. Sunrise on the Reaping needs a nine-figure opening just to be called a success.

There's also an Oscar campaign riding on this. World of Reel argues that a big opening "would only help the film's Oscar chances," and a crowd-pleaser holding over the holidays is precisely how a Best Picture contender builds momentum.

And then there's the original, the ultimate benchmark for this kind of story. Rocky was made for around $1 million in 1976 and earned $225 million worldwide. Its biopic costs about 25 times more and won't come anywhere close to that ratio. But if it opens second to one of the year's biggest franchise launches and keeps going through December, it'll have done exactly what its subject did fifty years ago: walked in as an afterthought and walked out with everyone's attention.

Previously we wrote: Digger closes at $50M: Tom Cruise got paid, Warner Bros. got the bill