'It's been written by Chat GPT?' — Fans Catch Bizarre Plot Error in 'And Just Like That'

In a show known for couture, cosmos, and the occasional character reinvention, one thing fans didn’t expect was a resurrection — of the accidental kind. In the latest episode of And Just Like That, Lisa Todd Wexley mourns the sudden loss of her father. Touching, right? Except… she’s already done that.

Back in Season 1, Lisa (played by Nicole Ari Parker) quietly confided to Charlotte that she, too, had lost her father — 'last year', in fact. Season 2 then threw in a twist, reintroducing her dad (played by Billy Dee Williams) for a posh dinner party scene. Now, Season 3 has him dying all over again, complete with funeral. Confused? You're not alone.

Reddit lit up with reactions. "They show him at dinner in the 'previously on' part," wrote CrunchyTaco9142 "So he died in Season 1, came to dinner in Season 2, and died in Season 3?!??". One user, KermitOfMinkHollow, summed it up with perfect deadpan: "When your dad has died twice in five years but you just know the writers are gonna kill him off again next year."

But the most pointed jab came from heyyou0903, who asked the question now etched across fan forums: "The writing is SO bad and the characters lack any substance so much surely it's been written by Chat GPT?"

HBO hasn’t offered a clear in-universe explanation, though some suggest the first father was actually Lisa’s stepfather. Perhaps. But in a show where wardrobe is sacred and storylines are fluid, this particular retcon has raised eyebrows. After all, a parent’s death is usually a one-time plot point — or so we thought.