Keira Knightley's Black Doves season 2 doesn't seem to be working out at all
Critics say season 2 is even better. Netflix's numbers say roughly two out of three viewers didn't come back.
Black Doves season 2 dropped all six episodes on Thursday, November 5, and opened with 3.8 million views and 19.9 million hours. That put it at No. 4 on Netflix's English TV list for November 2–8, behind a Natalee Holloway docuseries, a Matthew Perry documentary and the third season of Nobody Wants This.
Season 1, which also premiered on a Thursday, opened with 10.8 million views. That's a drop of about 65 percent, apples to apples.
Critics say season 2 is better than season 1. It opened to about a third of season 1's audience.
The reviews are not the problem
This is what makes the drop so strange. The critics are, if anything, warmer this time. Inverse says season 2 is even more of a blast. TheWrap's review headline says the show gets even better. Tom's Guide gave it four out of five stars and called it the answer to Slow Horses withdrawal. Knightley and Ben Whishaw are back, Sarah Lancashire is still running the Doves, and the new cast includes Neve Campbell, Ambika Mod, Sam Riley and Sylvia Hoeks.

Netflix believed in it, too. It renewed Black Doves in August 2024, before season 1 even aired.
What went wrong
Three things, and none of them is Keira Knightley:
- The wait. Season 1 premiered in December 2024. Season 2 came almost two years later. That's the same gap killing The Rings of Power, and a six-episode spy thriller has less brand loyalty to burn than Tolkien does.
- The calendar. Season 1 was a Christmas thriller released at Christmas; Empire called it the perfect Christmas gift from Netflix. Season 2 arrived in early November, without the holiday hook that made the first one a seasonal event.
- The company. It launched into a week Netflix's own true crime ate alive. Taken: Natalee Holloway pulled 12.9 million views, more than three times Black Doves.
By one comparison, the season 2 opening ranks 13th out of 14 similar Netflix thrillers. And this isn't a lack of interest in the UK: Black Doves was the country's most-searched series on November 8, ranked No. 2 on Netflix's UK list for the week, and debuted at No. 1 in Germany. The audience exists. It just didn't show up in the numbers Netflix uses to make decisions.
Don't miss: Concrete proof that Joran van der Sloot has been lying all along
The case for patience, and why it's a long shot
There's one real argument for optimism. Season 1 grew in its second week, rising from 10.8 million views to 14.6 million and taking No. 1. Netflix's November 9–15 chart, due tonight, will show season 2's first full week.
But season 1 grew from a strong start. Season 2 would need to nearly quadruple just to match season 1's second week. What's on Netflix already calls the show's renewal uncertain.
Creator Joe Barton has been here before. Giri/Haji, his previous Netflix series, got raves and was canceled after one season. Black Doves has already done better than that by a season. Whether it gets a third depends on whether the people who loved season 1 find out season 2 exists before Netflix runs the math.
Previously we wrote: Rings of Power season 3 proves a mediocre show can't survive a two-year wait