The Big Bang Theory only exists thanks to two different sitcom pitches merged into one
Chuck Lorre wanted a show about a young woman starting her adult life. Bill Prady wanted one about the nerds he used to be. Only one of them really got his show.
The most-watched comedy of its era started as two separate ideas. TVLine lays out how Chuck Lorre was developing a show about a young woman "getting her life started at the beginning of adulthood," while Bill Prady pitched one about 1980s computer programmers "failing at romantic relationships." Lorre told Collider that Prady's characters "took over," so they asked what would happen if the two ideas became one.
The programmers became physicists, and Lorre explained why:
"They're not entrepreneurs. They're scientists. That freed us up from a lot of clichés."
— Chuck Lorre, to Collider
Prady's half was autobiography. He'd worked in the computer business in New York in his early twenties and struggled with romance, and he told Variety in 2019 that he knew he'd only get one chance to tell those stories. He agreed to change the characters' jobs but refused to change who they were. Sheldon and Leonard were two warring sides of Prady's own personality at the time.
"It's the story of that time in my life and I knew I'd get one shot to tell those stories."
— Bill Prady, to Variety
The pilot nobody saw
The merged version didn't work on the first try. The 2006 unaired pilot, directed by James Burrows, had Leonard and Sheldon but no Howard and no Raj. In their place were two women:
- Katie (Amanda Walsh): a street-hardened, tough-as-nails woman with a vulnerable side, who moves in with the guys after finding out her boyfriend is married. Test audiences found her too abrasive.
- Gilda (Iris Bahr): a scientist colleague with a crush on Leonard and a past fling with Sheldon at a Star Trek convention.
CBS only asked them to recast Katie. Lorre thought the problem went deeper:
"Our script didn't fully realize what our possibilities were."
— Chuck Lorre, via TVLine
The second pilot cut both women. Katie became Penny (Kaley Cuoco), a sweeter neighbor across the hall. Gilda disappeared, later reworked into Sara Gilbert's Leslie Winkle. Howard and Raj joined, and Sheldon was rebuilt as more insular and childlike.
Don't miss: The Big Bang Theory's season 9 premiere was its first red flag before the downfall
Whose show it became
By any business measure, the merger was a triumph: 12 seasons, 10 Emmys, 279 episodes, and a franchise that kept going with Young Sheldon, Georgie & Mandy's First Marriage and Stuart Fails to Save the Universe.

But look at what happened to each half. Prady's programmers became the center of the show, with his own personality split across its two leads. Lorre's young woman starting her adult life became the neighbor. Penny's story played out mostly in relation to the guys, and the show never gave her a maiden name. The two women from the first pilot were cut, and the show didn't add more until Bernadette and Amy arrived in season 3.
Chuck Lorre's half of the pitch was about a young woman starting her adult life. In the show it became, she never got a last name of her own.
Three spinoffs later, the franchise has given full shows to Sheldon's childhood, his brother's marriage and the guy who runs the comic book store. The young woman from the original pitch is still waiting for hers.
Previously we wrote: The heartbreaking reason the Friends cast refused to join Matthew Perry's Netflix doc