The Gilded Age gay couple: who plays Oscar's new love interest, and where you've seen him before

The Gilded Age gay couple: who plays Oscar's new love interest, and where you've seen him before
Image credit: Legion Media

That's James Scully as painter Lee Klein. You've seen him play a killer, a killer's brother and Mr. Bingley, and this isn't even his first 19th-century role.

Spoilers ahead for The Gilded Age season 4, episode 3, "Ain't That Good News."

Oscar van Rhijn (Blake Ritson) finally has someone to flirt with again. At the first salon thrown by Oscar and his new wife Enid (Kelley Curran), Enid steers him toward a young artist: "Oh, Oscar, darling, have you met Mr. Chase's apprentice, Lee Klein? He's quite the talent. He just sold his first painting."

Then she walks away to let Oscar pick out a picture, and the air changes. Lee's opening line is pure Julian Fellowes subtext: "Maybe I can persuade you to the merits of art." Oscar says he's welcome to try.

Lee Klein is played by James Scully, and if he looks familiar, there's a good reason.

Who is Lee Klein?

Lee is a fictional character, but his teacher isn't. William Merritt Chase was one of the most influential American painters of the late 19th century, and his New York studio was a social scene in its own right. The official description of Lee is short and promising: "an artist who sells his first painting at an unforgettable Society event."

James Scully with Conrad Ricamora and Nick Adams in Fire Island (2022). Scully played Charlie, the Mr. Bingley figure in the film’s retelling of Pride and Prejudice.
James Scully with Conrad Ricamora and Nick Adams in Fire Island (2022). Scully played Charlie, the Mr. Bingley figure in the film’s retelling of Pride and Prejudice. Image credit: Legion Media

He arrives at the right moment for Oscar. Over the last two seasons, Oscar lost the van Rhijn fortune to a scam investment and then lost John Adams (Claybourne Elder), who was killed off in season 3. Season 4 opened with his lavender marriage to Enid, a wealthy widow and former lady's maid who knows exactly what she's getting.

Oscar married Enid for money and position. Now he's about to find out whether a marriage of convenience is convenient enough to hide a love affair.

For that to work, Lee has to be charming enough to be worth the risk. Enter Scully.

Where you've seen James Scully before

Scully, 34, has quietly built a résumé full of characters you remember even if you don't remember his name:

  • You (Netflix). His breakout: Forty Quinn, Love Quinn's chaotic twin brother, across 11 episodes of season 2, with a return in season 3.
  • Heathers (2018). He played J.D., the role Christian Slater made famous, in Paramount Network's TV reboot.
  • Fire Island (2022). In Joel Kim Booster's queer retelling of Pride and Prejudice, he's Charlie, the show's Mr. Bingley. So he's already played a romantic lead in a period-drama story, just in swim trunks.
  • Titans. Nine episodes as Bernard Fitzmartin.
  • Oh, Mary! (Broadway). He originated Mary's Teacher in Cole Escola's unhinged Mary Todd Lincoln comedy, first off-Broadway and then in his Broadway debut in 2024.

That last one makes Lee Klein a homecoming of sorts. Scully has already spent long stretches of the last two years in 1865, playing a handsome young man who walks into a famous household and changes the course of a marriage. The Gilded Age just moved him two decades forward and asked him to keep his voice down.

Don't miss: Miss Scarlet and the Duke season 7 release date: the final season is set, and Ivy won't be in it

Why this romance is "a dangerous game"

Blake Ritson is thrilled to see Oscar happy for once. "Having seen Oscar, in his own words, descending to the innermost circles of hell for two seasons, this rollercoaster just going steadily down, it's been fantastic," he told TVLine. He's loved watching Oscar on "a really hedonistic run. He's canoodling and cocktailing and dancing."

But he's also clear about what's at stake in 1880s New York:

"To forge a relationship in society like that, it's a dangerous game. There are such huge social and legal ramifications, were anything to even progress to the stage of being gossip."

— Blake Ritson, Oscar van Rhijn

Ritson points to Edith Wharton's image of society as "a small and slippery pyramid," and Oscar and Enid have only just climbed to the top. That makes Lee a problem inside the marriage too. "This is a point of contention between the two of them," Ritson says. "How does one engage in a relationship but keep oneself entirely safe at the same time?"

His answer: "It's a real balancing act, for sure."

With five episodes left in the season, Oscar has plenty of time to lose his balance. The only question is whether Lee Klein ends up as the love of Oscar's life or the gossip that brings down the house of van Rhijn.

Previously we wrote: How to watch Sharknado in order before Fin and April's origin story arrives in July 2027