There's an error in Boston Blue only true Blue Bloods fans will notice
Danny Reagan just called Joe his older brother. For seven seasons of Blue Bloods, Danny was the oldest Reagan, and the actor who played him through all fourteen is an executive producer on the spinoff.
The line comes in "Blood Diamonds," Boston Blue season 2, episode 5, the one built entirely around a Reagan reunion. Jamie (Will Estes) is in town, the brothers are mid-argument, and Danny (Donnie Wahlberg) says they "lost our older brother, Joe." Screen Rant's Cher Thompson calls it a major plot hole, and for anyone who watched Blue Bloods from the beginning, the sibling order was settled: Danny, Erin, Joe, Jamie.
Except Blue Bloods itself never kept it settled.
How the Reagans lost track of their own birth order
- Before the pilot: Joe Reagan is killed in the line of duty on May 15, 2009, fifteen months before season 1 begins. His tombstone gives a 1977 birth year, and the exact date later changes from June 6 to January 4.
- Seasons 1–7: Dialogue establishes Danny as the eldest. Looper notes that a few season 1 lines already hinted at the opposite, so the show was contradicting itself almost from day one.
- Season 8: The retcon starts. Frank calls Joe his eldest child as late as season 8, episode 7.
- Season 10 finale, "Family Secrets": The Reagans meet Joe Hill (Will Hochman), the son Joe never knew he had. Making Joe the oldest brother gave his son a stronger claim to the family legacy, and that version became the one the show kept repeating.
The confusion has outlived the show. Even Wikipedia can't agree with itself: Danny's page calls him the eldest son, while Erin's family box lists Joe as her oldest brother.
For seven seasons, Danny Reagan was the oldest Reagan child. Then Blue Bloods needed a backstory for Joe's son, and the dead brother aged up.
The line came from the one person who should know
Boston Blue didn't invent this mistake. It picked a side, the later one, which Blue Bloods had been pushing as fact for its last seven seasons. A spinoff following the most recent canon is defensible on paper.

It's harder to defend in this scene. Of every Reagan, Danny is the one who would know whether he's the oldest. He said it to Jamie, the only other living brother in the room and the one person who could correct him. And the actor delivering the line spent fourteen seasons playing the big brother and is now an executive producer on the show. Screen Rant says most fans still consider Danny the oldest, and Wahlberg's own early seasons are the reason why.
Don't miss: Boston Blue S2 brings back a familiar Blue Bloods face, and it's the perfect casting
More Reagans, more chances
Co-creators Brandon Margolis and Brandon Sonnier have promised more Blue Bloods cameos this season, and Screen Rant expects Eddie (Vanessa Ray) and Jamie's son to follow. Every visit is another Reagan family dinner, and another chance for somebody at the table to finally ask the question the franchise has dodged since 2017: which one of you is actually older?
Previously we wrote: One Marshals change Luke Grimes really struggled with