5 Best Supernatural Thrillers Like 'Dark' to Binge Right Now

Who doesn’t like shows that make you analyze philosophical questions in a dark and creepy atmosphere? If you think that it’s a tricky question, you probably have never watched Netflix’s Dark, so before continuing reading this article, go change that first. Those who love the series’ eerie atmosphere and who are craving for more, stay with us.

The supernatural thriller is a complex genre, filled with brain-teasing stories that will keep you glued to your screen and questioning reality long after the credits roll. And here are 5 perfect shows to binge right now, handpicked by us.

1. ‘1899’ (2022)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, 1899 has 77% from critics and 74% from viewers.
• On IMDb, 1899 has 7.3/10.

From the creators of Dark, 1899 is a must-watch for fans of that series. Set aboard a migrant steamship heading from Europe to America, the show explores the mysterious disappearance of another ship, the Prometheus.

As the crew and passengers uncover strange symbols and distorted realities, the show weaves a rather cryptic story filled with puzzles and philosophical questions. Its multilingual cast and period setting add layers of tension, and although the show was canceled after one season, its compelling atmosphere and unanswered questions make it an essential follow-up for Dark devotees.

2. ‘The OA’ (2016-2019)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, The OA has 84% from critics and 83% from viewers.
• On IMDb, The OA has 7.8/10.

A blend of supernatural mystery and speculative science fiction, The OA is a genre-defying series that explores near-death experiences that go hand in hand with interdimensional travel and the exploration of human capacity for belief.

When Prairie Johnson returns home after being missing for seven years, with her blindness mysteriously cured, she gathers a group of strangers to share her story. Rich in symbolism, the series dives into the metaphysical with confidence, making it a perfect choice for the next binge after Dark.

We have to warn you, though: The OA was canceled before the story could receive a definitive resolution.

3. ‘Twin Peaks’ (1990-1991)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, Twin Peaks has 78% from critics and 92% from viewers.
• On IMDb, Twin Peaks has 8.7/10.

There was no way this cult classic from David Lynch was going to be omitted in a list like this because Twin Peaks is a show that redefined the supernatural mystery genre. Following the murder of high school student Laura Palmer, FBI agent Dale Cooper arrives in a small town where nothing is as it seems. Only to find out that the place is haunted and all the people have secrets.

The show combines surreal horror with quirky humor, creating a unique world that’s both bizarre and addictive. Parallel dimensions, prophetic visions and just so many strange entities is what makes this show truly one of a kind.

4. ‘The Leftovers’ (2014-2017)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, The Leftovers has 82% from critics and 85% from viewers.
• On IMDb, The Leftovers has 8.3/10.

What if 2% of the world’s population suddenly vanished? The Leftovers, based on Tom Perrotta’s novel, picks up three years after a global disappearance event, exploring how those left behind grapple with grief, still trying to have faith in their future. While not strictly supernatural in the traditional sense, the series delves into psychological and metaphysical themes that are still haunting enough to be appreciated by Dark fans.

5. ‘Fringe’ (2008-2013)

• On Rotten Tomatoes, Fringe has 90% from critics and 80% from viewers.
• On IMDb, Fringe has 8.4/10.

Another highly praised series, Fringe, created by J.J. Abrams, is a perfect mix of procedural drama with science fiction and the supernatural. Centered around a special FBI division investigating bizarre phenomena, the show explores parallel universes, diving deep into mind control techniques and other fringe sciences.