Best Medicine isn't just a Doc Martin remake: its showrunner points to two shows instead

Best Medicine isn't just a Doc Martin remake: its showrunner points to two shows instead
Image credit: Legion Media

Liz Tuccillo's elevator pitch for Fox's Doc Martin remake didn't mention Doc Martin.

Best Medicine premiered on Fox in January 2026. Josh Charles plays Dr. Martin Best, a Boston surgeon who develops a fear of blood and ends up as the general practitioner in Port Wenn, Maine, the fishing village where he spent childhood summers. Abigail Spencer plays schoolteacher Louisa, Annie Potts plays his Aunt Sarah, Josh Segarra is Sheriff Mark Mylow, and Cree is his assistant Elaine.

The British Doc Martin ran on ITV from 2004 to 2022, with Martin Clunes as the grumpy doctor, and had already been remade in France, Germany, Spain, Greece, the Netherlands and the Czech Republic. Clunes even turned up in the American version as Martin's father.

Is Best Medicine a Doc Martin remake?

On paper, yes, and the pilot proves it. It follows the British original closely, from Martin's insulting first meeting with Louisa to the medical mystery of the week. After that, the writers tried to keep borrowing from the original, and it didn't work.

"We ended up having to change it so much, it became unrecognizable," Tuccillo said.

So most of Best Medicine's cases are its own. The pace is different too, and the American version is in less of a hurry. "In the British show, things accelerated so much faster," Charles told the Los Angeles Times.

The shows Tuccillo actually pitched

When Tuccillo, whose credits include Sex and the City, described the show, she didn't reach for Cornwall.

"I was calling it Northern Exposure meets House: Kooky people and a curmudgeonly doctor," Tuccillo told The Daily Beast.

Both halves fit. Northern Exposure ran on CBS from 1990 to 1995 and sent a New York doctor to practice in a tiny Alaska town full of eccentrics. House gave Fox eight seasons of a brilliant doctor who couldn't stand his patients. Best Medicine takes the town from one and the doctor from the other.

People gather in a field in Best Medicine (2026). Showrunner Liz Tuccillo drew on Northern Exposure for the small town around her curmudgeonly doctor.
People gather in a field in Best Medicine (2026). Showrunner Liz Tuccillo drew on Northern Exposure for the small town around her curmudgeonly doctor. Image credit: Legion Media

It's a remake of a British show, pitched in American shorthand. The cast has its own version of the pitch. "It's like Northern Exposure and Doc Hollywood and Schitt's Creek had a baby," Abigail Spencer told TV Insider. The baby's three parents:

  • Northern Exposure — the same pick as Tuccillo's.
  • Doc Hollywood — the 1991 Michael J. Fox comedy about a big-city doctor stuck in a small town.
  • Schitt's Creek — the one that isn't about medicine at all.

Between Tuccillo and Spencer, Northern Exposure is the only title on both lists. It's also the only '90s TV show on either.

Don't miss: The Big Bang Theory only exists thanks to two different sitcom pitches merged into one

What's different in season 2

The pitch worked. Fox renewed Best Medicine on March 2, before season 1 had even finished, and season 2 premiered on September 20. Two Port Wenn regulars got promoted: Stephen Spinella and Jason Veasey, who play Greg and George, the married couple behind The Salty Breeze restaurant.

The town is also cutting back on its festivals. Season 1 had a lot of them, and season 2 has fewer, with more weight on each.

"We will be going bigger with the ones that we have," Tuccillo told TV Insider.

One of them is a crate race, which writer Cindy Chupack found by Googling fun small-town activities. It's also a way back into Martin's childhood summers and his relationship with Aunt Sarah.

Port Wenn itself is modeled on Corea, Maine, a village east of Acadia National Park that Tuccillo's friends pointed her to. The show is filmed in Upstate New York instead, partly in a town called Cornwall-on-Hudson. Doc Martin was filmed in Cornwall too. The other one.

Previously we wrote: 10 years later, Emilia Clarke's forgotten tearjerker blows up Netflix's top 10