Dexter: Resurrection's Five Borough Killer taunts police like the Zodiac, and Clyde Phillips explains why

Dexter: Resurrection's Five Borough Killer taunts police like the Zodiac, and Clyde Phillips explains why
Image credit: Legion Media

The Zodiac called the police after he killed. Dan Stevens' new villain calls before. According to the showrunner, it's exactly the kind of fame Dexter Morgan has always secretly wanted.

Three episodes into Dexter: Resurrection season 2, New York has a new celebrity, and it isn't Dexter. Lucas Stark (Dan Stevens), who has named himself the Five Borough Killer, has already pulled off two murders on schedule, and he announced both of them to the NYPD in advance.

Paramount+ didn't hide the inspiration. The official description says Stark, "in the manner of the still-unsolved Zodiac Killer case, taunts police with threats to murder innocent citizens — and then makes good, so to speak, on his threats." In the October 30 premiere, he does exactly that, phoning in his first warning:

"This is the Five Borough Killer. I will kill a New Yorker at a baseball game tomorrow. Consider yourself warned."

— Lucas Stark, season 2 premiere

He keeps his word, shooting a woman while declaring "Nobody cares," and then AirDrops the video of the killing to a stranger buried in her phone. In episode 2, he calls again, promising a death on Broadway, lures a repairman onto a roof with a fake AC job and pushes him. The body lands on a newsstand, practically on top of Dexter and Charley (Uma Thurman).

So how much Zodiac is actually in him? And why does a show about the world's most private serial killer suddenly need the world's loudest one?

The Zodiac playbook, updated for 2026

The parallels are hard to miss, but the differences tell you more about the character:

  • The phone calls. The real Zodiac called Vallejo police in July 1969 to say, "I want to report a double murder." He called after the shooting. Stark calls before. The Zodiac was bragging. Stark is booking an audience.
  • The self-branding. The Zodiac named himself and opened his letters with "This is the Zodiac speaking." Stark opens his first call with "This is the Five Borough Killer." Neither waited for the press to pick a nickname.
  • The media. The Zodiac mailed letters and ciphers to San Francisco newspapers. Stark skips the newspapers and AirDrops his murders straight to strangers' phones.
  • The ending. The Zodiac was never caught. That's the one part of the playbook Dexter Morgan has no intention of letting Stark copy.

Stevens himself sees more than one real killer in the role. He told Romania's Playtech that Stark has "a bit of Zodiac" and "a bit of Son of Sam, the story that captivated New York in the '70s" (translated from Romanian). That's the more local reference: David Berkowitz also wrote taunting letters to the NYPD and to columnist Jimmy Breslin while the city panicked.

New York even had a real Zodiac copycat. Between 1989 and 1996, a killer calling himself the New York Zodiac killed three people and wounded five across the boroughs, and wrote taunting letters too. A show that put a Zodiac-style killer in New York didn't have to invent much.

"We didn't sit down and say, 'Let's do the Zodiac'"

According to Clyde Phillips, the resemblance was an accident the writers only noticed later. Speaking to TVLine, the showrunner said the Five Borough Killer was born in the writers' room in Los Angeles, and only then did somebody point out the obvious: "You know, that is not dissimilar to Zodiac."

"We didn't sit down in the room and say, 'Hey, let's do the Zodiac Killer.'"

— Clyde Phillips, showrunner

Once the comparison was on the table, Phillips said, the team owed it to the audience not to just copy the real case: "Then it is our obligation to make it our own."

Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan in Dexter: Resurrection (2025). The Five Borough Killer gains a kind of public recognition that Dexter has always wanted.
Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan in Dexter: Resurrection (2025). The Five Borough Killer gains a kind of public recognition that Dexter has always wanted. Image credit: Legion Media

Their version of making it their own has nothing to do with ciphers. It has to do with Dexter's ego.

Why he's really here: Dexter is jealous

Phillips explained the real reason to Entertainment Weekly. Stark, he said, "is killing in each borough to terrorize the city." And the person most bothered by it isn't the NYPD:

"In his own weird midlife crisis way, one of the things that Dexter has always wanted is recognition. At the end of Season 1 of the original series, we have the scene where he's being feted with confetti and people cheering him on and an airplane goes by with 'I heart Dexter.' As independent as he likes to think he is, he wants that recognition, and by the time the Five Borough Killer has killed one person, he already has the city in his grip. And that drives Dexter f---ing crazy, because nobody knows who he is."

— Clyde Phillips, showrunner

Think about what Dexter has had instead of fame. In the original series, the Bay Harbor Butcher got headlines and an FBI task force, but never a face. Dexter spent eight seasons making sure nobody knew, then two revivals proving he couldn't stop. Now a younger killer gets famous after a single body, and Dexter can't even complain about it to anyone.

Brian Cox's New York Ripper is who Dexter is afraid of becoming. Dan Stevens' Five Borough Killer is who he secretly wishes he'd been.

That's why the season splits its villains by age. Phillips frames season 2 as Dexter's midlife crisis, and both new killers are mirrors: the old legend who never got caught and the newcomer who got famous overnight.

Don't miss: MobLand's new villain has fans dubbing him the next Heath Ledger Joker

Stevens is ready to let him go

Stevens, who bleached his hair for the part, isn't sentimental about his killer either. He called the show "such a fun family to join," and then added a warning:

"It's a great set to be on, and it's a really nasty character. As much as I've enjoyed it, I'll be happy to let him go."

— Dan Stevens, to The Hollywood Reporter

Dexter, for his part, is already counting. After the Broadway kill, Dexter sums up the situation in voiceover: "Okay, that's two - still not a serial killer." He's planning to stop Stark before number three.

Episode 4 drops Friday, November 20, on Paramount+. Stark has already done the one thing the Zodiac never did: he told the police exactly how many stops are on his tour. There are five boroughs, and he's only on his second murder.

Previously we wrote: There's an error in Boston Blue only true Blue Bloods fans will notice