The slasher Gene Siskel hated so much he gave away the killer in the Chicago Tribune

The slasher Gene Siskel hated so much he gave away the killer in the Chicago Tribune
Image credit: Legion Media

Usually, the worst thing a filmmaker could get from Gene Siskel was a bad review. On Monday, May 12, 1980, the people who'd made one particular movie might have been quite grateful for a bad review.

The movie was Friday the 13th. It opened on Friday, May 9. By the time Siskel's review appeared on page A3 of the Chicago Tribune, Paramount already had the opening weekend's money. The critic had an idea about what to do with the people who were still deciding whether to go.

What Chicago got for the price of a newspaper

In Sean S. Cunningham's film, a group of young counselors is getting Camp Crystal Lake ready to reopen. Somebody starts picking them off. The camera lets you look through the killer's eyes quite a bit, which is a neat way of giving you a very good seat and a very bad look at the one person you'd like to identify.

Siskel took care of that. The killer is Mrs. Voorhees, played by Betsy Palmer. Her son Jason drowned at camp while the counselors who should have been watching him were otherwise occupied. And if you hoped to salvage a little suspense over whether she got away with it, Siskel gave away the decapitation, too. “I hope I've ruined Friday the 13th,” he wrote. He'd just spent several paragraphs giving himself an excellent chance.

Most bad reviews leave you free to disagree for the price of a ticket. Siskel made sure nobody who read his could ever see the same movie he did.

Imagine taking him up on it anyway. When Palmer finally appears, Alice thinks an adult has arrived to help. A reader who bought the Tribune that Monday is now waiting for Alice to catch up with the morning paper.

Don't miss: Crystal Lake ending explained: the finale answers the one question Friday the 13th left hanging since 1980

The clue Siskel saved everybody the trouble of hearing

Composer Harry Manfredini had put the solution on the soundtrack. He needed a way to tell us when the prowling camera belonged to the killer. As Manfredini explained in an interview, he listened to Palmer doing Jason's voice, urging his mother to kill. He took the opening sounds of kill and mommy, whispered them into a microphone and added an echo. That little ki-ki-ki, ma-ma-ma has been telling on Mrs. Voorhees the whole time.

Adrienne King as Alice in a canoe in Friday the 13th (1980). Gene Siskel's review of the film revealed the killer's identity.
Adrienne King as Alice in a canoe in Friday the 13th (1980). Gene Siskel's review of the film revealed the killer's identity. Image credit: Legion Media

The movie went on to earn nearly $40 million in North America. And sixteen years later, in the opening of Scream, Ghostface asks Casey Becker who the killer was in the original Friday the 13th. She says Jason. For once in horror history, a girl really would have been better off reading the Chicago Tribune.

Previously we wrote: Friday the 13th fans waited 17 years for Crystal Lake. Peacock's record won't buy them season 2