George R.R. Martin's least favorite scene in all 8 seasons of Game of Thrones

George R.R. Martin's least favorite scene in all 8 seasons of Game of Thrones
Image credit: Legion Media

If you had money on a dragon, keep your wallet out. When George R.R. Martin picked the scene that bothered him most, one of the things he wished HBO had sprung for was a dog.

It's Robert Baratheon's hunting trip in “A Golden Crown,” six episodes into season 1. The man rules seven kingdoms. For his big day out he can apparently muster his little brother Renly, one knight of the Kingsguard and the Lannister boy in charge of the wine. All four are on foot. Somewhere in Westeros there must be a village wedding with better attendance.

What Martin actually wrote

Here's the funny thing about this particular beef with an adaptation. Open A Game of Thrones and you won't find some glorious boar hunt the showrunners hacked down to size. Robert goes out. Word comes back that he's been gored. By the time Ned sees his friend again, the maesters can do very little for him. Martin left the hunt off the page. HBO put it on screen and had to account for everybody who should have been there.

In James Hibberd's oral history Fire Cannot Kill a Dragon, Martin described a royal expedition of a hundred men, complete with huntsmen, dogs, horns and pavilions. Then he gave a rather practical reason for the four gentlemen taking a walk.

“But at that point, we couldn't afford horses or dogs or pavilions.”

There is good business in those woods. Mark Addy's Robert is having a marvelous time remembering the good old days, right up to the moment Renly reminds him what those days were like for people on the receiving end. Renly stalks off. Lancel offers the king more wine. Keep an eye on the helpful young man with the wineskin. Cersei has found a much quieter way to get rid of a husband than hiring somebody with a sword.

Mark Addy as Robert Baratheon in Game of Thrones (2011). George R.R. Martin singled out this royal hunting scene because the show could afford so few people and props
Mark Addy as Robert Baratheon in Game of Thrones (2011). George R.R. Martin singled out this royal hunting scene because the show could afford so few people and props. Image credit: Legion Media

What HBO could buy by season 2

When the producers got to the Battle of the Blackwater, they went back to HBO for more money. They got an extra $2 million and another week to shoot. Martin wrote that episode himself and still had to give up the bridge of smashed ships from his novel. The crew built a boat in a parking lot. Shooting at night spared them some expensive backgrounds and made the green wildfire look terrific.

It's a lovely distinction. You can watch “Blackwater” and feel as though you've seen a fleet. Watch Robert hunt and you can practically count who got paid that day.

Don't miss: Percy Jackson and the Olympians cast age: the actors' real ages forced Rick Riordan to rethink a prophecy

The prequel finally took a king hunting

For little Aegon's second birthday in House of the Dragon, the court follows Viserys to the Kingswood. There are tents, servants, gossiping lords and a Lannister with an ornate spear to present. The guests can read a succession crisis into the color of a deer. By the time Viserys gets to the stag, other men have already roped it in place for him. The king's job is to deliver the killing blow in front of witnesses. Meanwhile Rhaenyra, his actual heir, encounters the white hart everyone wanted and lets it walk.

A king can miss the stag. What he can't do is leave the entire court at home and still show us what it means to be king.

That's what the extra bodies buy you. Take the guests out of Viserys's hunt and you lose the people trying to pressure him into replacing his daughter. Take the wine boy out of Robert's and the king might actually make it home for dinner. Of the three men HBO could afford to send with him, at least they kept the right one.

Previously we wrote: Marvel's "record" VisionQuest finale still couldn't beat Loki