I Play Rocky Oscar predictions: can Ippolito win Best Actor playing the man who lost it?
Fifty years ago, Sylvester Stallone lost Best Actor to a man who had died that January. Now a 27-year-old from Long Island wants to finish the job. I've run the numbers, and I have a verdict.
The Academy has a type. It loves actors who disappear into real performers, it loves a comeback story, and it really loves a movie about how hard it is to make movies. I Play Rocky checks all three boxes.
It also has two problems that nobody at Amazon MGM wants to talk about. One of them is named Ryan Gosling. The other is a record that no actor in Oscar history has managed to break.
Where Ippolito stands right now
Let's start with the cold facts. In Scott Feinberg's mid-October forecast at The Hollywood Reporter, Ippolito sat at No. 7 in Best Actor, outside the top five. The names ahead of him are heavy: Andrew Scott for Elsinore, John Malkovich for Wild Horse Nine, Matt Damon for The Odyssey and Ryan Gosling for Project Hail Mary.
Prediction market Kalshi is a little kinder. It gives him roughly a coin flip at a nomination, and a 7% chance of actually winning, far behind Malkovich.

The film came out of Toronto as a genuine crowd favorite, finishing first runner-up for the People's Choice Award behind La Bola Negra. The reviews for the movie are mixed. The reviews for him mostly aren't. The A.V. Club wrote the film "would simply not work without Ippolito's excellent performance," and even /Film, which called the movie "syrupy," headlined its review with his "uncanny lead performance." His director is less measured:
"You're looking at Anthony because it's a generational performance."
— Peter Farrelly, to the Los Angeles Times
So he's in the conversation. Here's why he could stay there, and why he might not.
The case for Ippolito
There are five good reasons to believe:
- The Academy rewards performer biopics. Jamie Foxx won for Ray. Rami Malek won for Bohemian Rhapsody. Playing a real star the audience knows by heart is one of the surest routes to the stage.
- The prep story sells itself. He hunted down every scrap of early Stallone footage, including a film he ordered from Japan and waited two months for, and yes, he drank the raw eggs. Once. "It's not natural, it's total work," he says.
- The narrative is irresistible. Stallone was nominated for Best Actor for Rocky in 1977 and lost to Peter Finch, who won posthumously for Network. He was nominated again, for Supporting Actor in Creed, in 2016 and lost to Mark Rylance. An Oscar for the man playing him would feel like the Academy finally paying a 50-year-old debt.
- Farrelly knows the road. His Green Book won TIFF's audience award in 2018 and Best Picture a few months later.
- The real Stallone is on board. He saw the film, and according to Ippolito, had "a very positive reaction."
On paper, that's a winning hand. Unfortunately, the Oscars aren't played on paper.
Don't miss: I Play Rocky takes on The Hunger Games. What's the box office prediction?
The case against
And four reasons to hold your bet:
- Amazon is campaigning against itself. Gosling's Project Hail Mary is also an Amazon MGM release, in the same category. Studios can push two actors, but money, screenings and voter attention aren't infinite, and Gosling is the bigger name.
- History is not on his side. The youngest Best Actor winner ever is Adrien Brody, who was 29 when he won for The Pianist. Ippolito will be 27 on Oscar night. A win wouldn't just be an upset. It would be a record.
- Impersonation gets you nominated, not crowned. Austin Butler was everywhere for Elvis and lost. Timothée Chalamet sang his own Dylan in A Complete Unknown and lost. Voters admire mimicry, but they don't always reward it.
- The movie isn't universally loved. Ippolito's performance holds up even in the bad reviews. The film around him doesn't always, and Best Actor winners usually come from Best Picture contenders.
Put both lists side by side, and the answer starts to take shape.
My prediction
Here's my call. Ippolito gets nominated. He doesn't win.
The nomination I'd bet on, slightly better than Kalshi's coin flip. The wide release this Friday should turn a festival favorite into a word-of-mouth hit, and that's exactly the kind of movie actors in the Academy go to see on their own. If anyone falls out of the current top five to make room, it's Gosling, and the Amazon campaign may quietly decide the young guy with the better story is the safer horse.
The win is a different fight. Malkovich has the veteran-overdue narrative, Scott has the early momentum, and the youngest-ever record is a very tall wall for a first major lead role. I'd put Ippolito's chances at around one in ten.
Ippolito is going to lose Best Actor for playing a man who lost Best Actor. It's the most Stallone outcome imaginable.
What would change my mind? A win at the Actor Awards, where his fellow actors vote, or box office that turns I Play Rocky into the season's breakout hit. Watch both closely after the holidays.
And if he does lose, he'll be in good company. Farrelly already wrote the ending for him: "In the end, Rocky doesn't win. Rocky survived. Stallone wins." For a 27-year-old in his first major lead, going the distance is the win.
Previously we wrote: Digger closes at $50M: Tom Cruise got paid, Warner Bros. got the bill