Emily Blunt lost Black Widow to a Jack Black movie she didn't even want to make
Marvel wanted Emily Blunt for Iron Man 2. 20th Century Fox wanted her for Gulliver's Travels, and Fox had a contract.
Before Scarlett Johansson zipped into Natasha Romanoff's catsuit, Marvel offered the role to Emily Blunt. She wanted it. She loved Iron Man, she wanted to work with Robert Downey Jr., and Iron Man 2 was about to start production. Then 20th Century Fox called and reminded her of something she'd signed years earlier.
In 2021, Blunt told Howard Stern the real story, after years of reports that she'd simply picked another movie:
"I actually do want to clean up the story. I was contracted to do 'Gulliver's Travels.' I didn't want to do 'Gulliver's Travels.'"
— Emily Blunt, on The Howard Stern Show
The fine print
The trap was set back in 2006. To get her breakout role in The Devil Wears Prada, Blunt signed what's called an optional picture deal with Fox: the studio could put her in another film of its choosing later. Fox's timing couldn't have been worse: it exercised the option for Gulliver's Travels, a Jack Black comedy loosely based on Jonathan Swift, at exactly the time Iron Man 2 needed her. Marvel wasn't going to hold a tentpole for her. The part went to Johansson.
Blunt called it "a bit of heartbreaker." She takes pride in the choices she makes, she said, and the films mean a lot to her, which is exactly why having one made for her hurt. She did the job anyway, playing Princess Mary of Lilliput, and she wants credit for her professionalism:
"I was never looking like a slapped arse on set, I would never do that."
— Emily Blunt, on The Howard Stern Show
What each movie became
Iron Man 2 opened in May 2010 and grossed more than $620 million worldwide. Johansson went on to play Black Widow across the next decade of Marvel, through The Avengers, Civil War, Endgame and her own solo film in 2021, which ended with her suing Disney over its streaming release.

Gulliver's Travels opened on Christmas Day 2010, got savaged by critics, and grossed about $237 million worldwide on a budget north of $100 million. Most people remember it, if at all, as the movie where Jack Black is giant.
Emily Blunt signed a Fox contract to get The Devil Wears Prada. Four years later, Fox used it to send her to Lilliput while Marvel cast someone else as Black Widow.
The twist
Here's the thing Blunt told Stern in the same interview that makes the story almost funny: she doesn't even like superhero movies.
"They're not up my alley. I don't like them. I really don't."
— Emily Blunt, on The Howard Stern Show
She said watching them can leave her a bit cold. Marvel never got her, and she built a career on the kind of choices she cares about: Edge of Tomorrow, Sicario, A Quiet Place, an Oscar nomination for Oppenheimer. When fans spent years fan-casting her as Sue Storm opposite her husband John Krasinski in Fantastic Four, she shut it down: "That is fan-casting. No one has received a phone call."
Fox's option clause cost her the most famous female superhero role of the 2010s. It may also have spared her a decade in a catsuit doing something she doesn't enjoy.
Previously we wrote: James Gunn's upcoming projects: he leaves DC Studios on December 1 but still has at least three DC titles in the works