Boston Blue season 2 proves it will never be Blue Bloods
Somewhere in the writers' room, somebody pitched a story about the first time Danny Reagan might have to discipline his own partner. I'd love to know who went next. That's a hell of a pitch to follow.
Apparently, the next guy had a shark. In season 2, episode 4 of Boston Blue, a severed arm falls out of a dead great white, and off go Danny and Lena to find the rest of a marine biologist. It's Danny's first day as a sergeant. You could watch most of the investigation with the sound off and never guess he'd been promoted.
What did Danny get with the new stripes?
An HR seminar, for a start. Danny comes out worried about treating Lena like a friend now that he might have to write her up. That's a lovely problem to give Donnie Wahlberg. Danny spent fourteen seasons on Blue Bloods certain he knew better than whoever happened to outrank him. Now there's a woman sitting next to him in the car who's entitled to feel the same way about him.
Lena points out that her own sister is her boss. By the end of the hour, Danny's comfortable joking with her again. Fair enough on Lena's part. Pretty convenient on the writers' part. TV Fanatic called the case “underwhelming”, which takes some doing when your opening piece of evidence has teeth.
Blue Bloods would have made Danny defend that promotion over dinner. Boston Blue lets him sleep off the HR seminar.
What I miss about the Reagan table is that Danny could make a perfectly good arrest on Friday and still have a lousy Sunday. Erin had to prosecute cases like his. Frank had to answer for the department. Neither had to let him finish a story the way he liked to tell it.

Reviewing the first season for The Globe and Mail, Amber Dowling saw the familiar format as “comforting to the procedural seekers out there”. I get the appeal. But the fun of Blue Bloods was watching people who knew exactly how a case was supposed to go disagree about whether it had gone right.
Boston has the makings of just such a dinner in this very episode. Sarah Silver revisits a rape conviction. An innocent man took a ten-year deal because a trial could have cost him thirty. Later, offered a shot at parole if he'd admit guilt again, he refused. Now there's something I'd have liked to hear a cop and a prosecutor argue about for a few minutes. We've got to get back to the fish.
Don't miss: It's high time we admit Blue Bloods wasted Stacy Keach for eight straight years
Sean came to Boston, too. Sort of.
Andrew Terraciano grew up playing Danny's son at that table. Mika Amonsen plays Sean as a Boston cop. Co-creator Brandon Margolis explained the recast to Parade, saying “the energy of a different performer felt organic to the story we were telling.”
I can see why they'd want an actor who works for this version of Sean. I can also see why fans who watched Terraciano grow up felt the loss. The whole reason it matters that Danny's boy is wearing a badge is that we remember the kid who used to pass the potatoes. Boston Blue keeps asking me to bring fourteen years of family history to dinner. I'd like it to let some of that history start an argument.
Previously we wrote: There's an error in Boston Blue only true Blue Bloods fans will notice