It's high time we admit Blue Bloods wasted Stacy Keach for eight straight years

It's high time we admit Blue Bloods wasted Stacy Keach for eight straight years
Image credit: Legion Media

At six in the morning, Archbishop Kevin Kearns is already in Frank Reagan's office. He saw the commissioner's press conference. The NYPD has the wrong man in custody. Yes, the suspect confessed. So did somebody else, and the archbishop is going to make Frank's morning considerably worse by declining to say who.

This is “The Reagan Way,” a season 12 episode of Blue Bloods, and about as good an argument as television has produced for giving Stacy Keach a key to the building.

Keach, who died November 10 at 85, played Mike Hammer on television and King Lear onstage. CBS had him opposite Tom Selleck from 2016 to 2024 and found room for him in 11 episodes across seven seasons. One of those was a wedding.

The one guy Frank couldn't pull rank on

Frank has a particular way of letting somebody know a conversation is over. He can do it sitting down. It works beautifully on people who would like to keep their jobs. Kevin already has a boss.

Watch what happens when Frank suggests that the man who confessed in church might have lied. “People don't lie in the confessional, Frank,” Kevin tells him. Keach delivers that with the confidence of a man speaking from professional experience. Unfortunately for him, the other man in the room also takes confessions for a living.

The Reagan family at a restaurant table in Blue Bloods (2010). Stacy Keach played Kevin Kearns in eleven episodes opposite Tom Selleck's Frank Reagan.
The Reagan family at a restaurant table in Blue Bloods (2010). Stacy Keach played Kevin Kearns in eleven episodes opposite Tom Selleck's Frank Reagan. Image credit: Legion Media

What Blue Bloods wasted was a friendship in which Frank could actually lose an argument and still want the man back in his office. Keach gives “Frank” the easy familiarity of someone who's known him for years. He can call the commissioner wrong in his own office and make it sound like less of an imposition than asking him to validate parking. Look at the range of things the writers could do with that familiarity:

  • May 2019, “Something Blue.” Kearns officiates at Jamie and Eddie's wedding. Frank walks Eddie down the aisle. For once, the two old friends have agreed in advance on precisely where Frank ought to stand.
  • November 2021, “Good Intentions.” A local priest wants the NYPD defunded. Suddenly it's Frank who could use a friend in the other man's department. Getting Kevin to do something about a priest turns out to be about as easy as getting Frank to do something about a cop.
  • October 2024, “Life Sentence.” A man wanted for murder will surrender in New York. Kevin wants Frank to help keep him from being sent to Ohio, where he could face execution. He knows exactly which friend to ask. He also knows what he's asking that friend to put on the line.

Between April 2020 and November 2021, Keach went an entire season without appearing. Imagine seeing Frank turn up at Kevin's door the morning after the Ohio argument. Would either of them bring it up? Would Kevin pour the coffee anyway? Selleck and Keach could have made a scene out of that. The Ohio case was Keach's last episode.

Don't miss: There's an error in Boston Blue only true Blue Bloods fans will notice

Even the showrunner had one more appearance in mind

After the series finale, showrunner Kevin Wade was asked who else he'd wanted back. He singled out Keach. Explaining what he could fit into the broadcast, Wade told TV Insider:

“We did the best we could in our usual 43 minutes and five seconds.”

Fair enough for the finale. It had a funeral, a family dinner and fourteen seasons of Reagans to see off. It's the eight years before it I'd like to discuss. Somebody at One Police Plaza could've picked up a phone. We know Kevin's awake at six.

Previously we wrote: How to watch 9-1-1 in order before you start season 10 or Nashville season 2