Is Spider-Man in Avengers: Doomsday? Andrew Garfield swore he wasn't in No Way Home either
In 2021, Jimmy Fallon gave Andrew Garfield a chance to explain why there was a picture going around of him on a Spider-Man set. Five years later, I suspect Garfield would pay good money to have answered that question differently.
As of November 18, Marvel hasn't confirmed any Spider-Man for Avengers: Doomsday. Tom Holland, Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire are all missing from Disney's published cast guide. Holland at least has a clue in an actual movie. Garfield has given us his word, which is where things generally start to go wrong.
What was Ned's app picking up?
At the end of the credits in Spider-Man: Brand New Day, Ned's Spidey Tracker picks up a signal. It's coming from space. Fair enough if that made you think of Doctor Doom. In the extra footage from Avengers: Endgame – Encore, Bruce Banner's equipment glitches just before Doom comes to collect him. The tracker glitches, too.
I'd buy the theory that Doom has business with Holland's Peter. I'd also quite like to see how a kid whose usual jurisdiction is Queens wound up that far from home. But all Ned has actually found is a signal. Nobody takes off a mask in that scene, and nobody says which movie we'll see him in next.
Don't miss: Avengers: Doomsday box office prediction: can it beat Endgame with Dune opening the same day?
Andrew Garfield has already tried saying it louder
In October 2025, Garfield sat down to answer fans' questions for GQ. Somebody asked whether his Spider-Man and Maguire's would both appear in Doomsday. You can hardly fault the clarity of the answer.
“No, unequivocally, fucking no!”
The trouble is, this is the man who told Jimmy Fallon the photo was Photoshopped. Three months later, Ned opened a portal in his grandmother's dining room and out stepped Garfield. To prove he was Spider-Man, he climbed onto the ceiling. To please Ned's grandmother, he cleaned the cobwebs while he was up there. That's a fair amount of work for a man who hadn't been on set.

When Variety put the Doomsday question to him again, Garfield denied it again. He could tell the absolute truth this time and get exactly the same reaction he got when he lied. Until the movie opens on December 18, I'd give Ned's app a slight edge over the interviews. At least it has picked up an actual Spider-Man signal.
Previously we wrote: The heartbreaking reason Avengers: Doomsday will be Patrick Stewart's last role