Marshals is the worst thing that ever happened to Kayce Dutton

Marshals is the worst thing that ever happened to Kayce Dutton
Image credit: Legion Media

Kayce Dutton worked out how to get his family out of the most expensive inheritance dispute on television for $1.25 an acre. For about the length of time it took CBS to order a spinoff, the deal held.

Marshals killed Monica Dutton before its first episode even began. Cancer took her between shows. Kayce gets a graveside scene, Tate gets a mother he'll have to remember, and Kelsey Asbille, who played her through five seasons of Yellowstone, gets no scene at all. Then Kayce's old SEAL buddy Cal offers him a way to put his particular skills to use. I liked those skills just fine. I also remember whom he was trying to get home to.

What $1.25 an acre bought him

In the Yellowstone finale, Kayce sells the ranch back to Thomas Rainwater's people at the price his ancestors paid for it. He keeps East Camp. It's a solution nobody else in the Dutton family could have come up with quite that way. Tate is John's grandson and Monica's son. Giving the land back to Broken Rock means the boy can have a future on it without spending his life defending it from his mother's people.

That's a choice about three people. Lose Monica and it changes the ending retrospectively. As one viewer put it after the premiere, “So much of how that show ended is really meaningless with Monica dying shortly after.” The part that stings is that a viewer who goes back and watches Kayce make the deal now knows something he doesn't. Enjoy the place, son. Mom won't get much use out of it.

Yellowstone spent five seasons getting Kayce home. Marshals needed him available for work on Sunday.

Cal's offer makes sense to Kayce. Going back to work with someone who knew him in uniform gives him a reason to get up the next morning. What bothers me is how much of Monica's life the writers were willing to spend on that one good morning for her husband.

Luke Grimes and Kelsey Asbille as Kayce and Monica in Yellowstone (2018). Marshals opens after Monica dies and sends Kayce back into uniform
Luke Grimes and Kelsey Asbille as Kayce and Monica in Yellowstone (2018). Marshals opens after Monica dies and sends Kayce back into uniform. Image credit: Legion Media

What Luke Grimes had to say to Kelsey Asbille

Showrunner Spencer Hudnut told The Hollywood Reporter that Asbille was unavailable. He and Grimes also had a story problem. As Hudnut explained to TV Insider, “We had to shake up his life, to get him off the ranch and into a new position.” Grimes called Asbille himself. “I worked up the courage to call,” he said.

That phone call gets to me more than the job offer. The show does give the loss a place in the world Monica came from. Other people on the reservation have developed cancer, and residents suspect pollution from a mine. Tate wants to do something about it. There was a story right there about a Broken Rock woman, her son and what was happening to her neighbors. The writers chose to let her husband tell it from the other side of her grave.

Season 2 made the case for keeping her

“Roughstock” opens at a rodeo, where Kayce and Rainwater get the small pleasure of seeing Tate enjoy himself. Then Mo's nephew Troy goes missing outside the marshals' jurisdiction. Kayce goes with Mo anyway. They find the stones Troy was collecting for a baby shower before they find his body. When the sheriff calls it suicide, we know enough about the man to understand why his uncle keeps looking.

Don't miss: CBS keeps moving Marshals around like it wants Yellowstone fans to give up

Mo Brings Plenty and his brother shared their family's experience of losing his nephew Cole with the writers. The fictional investigation establishes that Troy was killed. It never supplies a killer. Mo gets a funeral and a private goodbye. For once the show understands that what a family has to live with after the deputies go home can carry an hour.

JoBlo called the first season a “forgettable procedural”. M.N. Miller was considerably fonder of season 2 when he compared it to “SWAT in chaps and funny hats” and singled out Grimes as a reason it works. I can see both shows in “Roughstock.” My favorite Kayce scene is still those few seconds at the rodeo. I'd have liked to see Monica see her kid that happy, too.

Previously we wrote: It's high time we admit Blue Bloods wasted Stacy Keach for eight straight years