Love Is Blind's divorced couple still hang out together after cheating scandal

Love Is Blind's divorced couple still hang out together after cheating scandal
Image credit: Legion Media

John Shannon told the Love Is Blind reunion that he'd texted a stripper who was also an escort. That night, he and Sarah Williams were having drinks in Burbank.

The Love Is Blind season 11 reunion gave Netflix its biggest bombshell of the Boston season. John Shannon and Sarah Williams, the only couple from the season who actually got married, were already divorced, and Nick Lachey wanted to know why. John eventually got there:

"I texted one of the people we met out that night, and nothing happened, but she saw the texts, and they were inappropriate for me to be sending as her husband."

— John Shannon, at the reunion

When Lachey asked whether that counted as cheating, John said, "I guess so, huh." Then he went further and told the room who the woman was: a stripper from a boys' night out who, he added, was also an escort.

The reunion was taped on October 24 and streamed on November 8. And according to photos TMZ obtained, on the same day they taped it, John and Sarah were out together at a bar in Burbank.

On October 24, John Shannon told Nick Lachey on camera that he'd texted a stripper who was also an escort. That night, he and Sarah were out at a bar in Burbank.

What the photos show

The night out wasn't a reconciliation, at least according to TMZ's witnesses. John and Sarah reportedly showed no PDA. They were there with fellow season 11 cast members Erika Ellis and Blake Carver, and the witnesses said Erika and Blake were the "touchy-feely" ones. The divorced couple were just two people having a drink after a very long day at work.

Don't miss: The heartbreaking reason Love Is Blind's only Boston marriage fell apart

That fits what Sarah said at the reunion itself: she told viewers she had forgiven John. The timeline behind it is short and brutal:

  • The wedding: John and Sarah married in the season 11 finale, filmed in 2025.
  • The texts: About a year into the marriage, John exchanged messages with the woman from the boys' night out.
  • The discovery: Sarah found the messages in April 2026, and they separated.
  • The divorce: Sarah filed on June 4.
  • The reunion: They taped it on October 24, then went out in Burbank.

The podcast version is harsher

Three days after the reunion aired, Sarah went on The Viall Files, and her account got sharper than anything she said with the Lacheys in the room. She said the messages were easy to find on John's phone, and that she'd started looking only after he was dishonest about a guys' trip, even though the two of them had already talked about strip clubs and she was fine with them. She also claimed she found an active Tinder profile with at least one match. John reportedly told her he hadn't used the app beyond that.

She described the marriage as one where John had suspected her of cheating over moments like a 45-minute gym trip during which she'd gone downstairs for a package and left the door ajar. By the end, she said, she'd stopped pushing back and had turned into "a meeker version of myself."

John, for his part, posted a video apology about a week after the reunion, owning the name-calling and unhealthy fights, and the texts:

"But I'd already crossed a line I never should have, and there's no excuse for that."

— John Shannon

So the friendliest moment of this divorce happened on the night of the reunion, away from the cameras, and the story has gotten sharper with every interview since. Hanging out after the taping and saying harsh things on podcasts aren't contradictions. They're two people who share a friend group, a divorce and a reality-TV afterlife, all at the same time.

Previously we wrote: Subpar Gold Rush season 17 has Parker seeing red: time to pull the plug?