6 movies Tarantino calls perfect, from Jaws to an ’80s time-travel comedy

6 movies Tarantino calls perfect, from Jaws to an ’80s time-travel comedy
Image credit: Legion Media

Jimmy Kimmel asked for a few more titles to go with Leatherface. Quentin Tarantino came up with a shark, a tap-dancing monster and one western he talked himself out of on the spot.

The conversation started with Tobe Hooper's The Texas Chain Saw Massacre. Tarantino had called it one of the few perfect movies ever made in Cinema Speculation, in a chapter ostensibly about another Hooper film, The Funhouse. On Jimmy Kimmel Live! in October 2022, Kimmel wanted to know which other movies met that standard.

“Might not be your cup of tea, but there's nothing you can say to bring it down,” Tarantino said.

You can dislike slasher movies and still have a hard time suggesting a single cut that would improve the last few minutes of Chain Saw. That's a tougher test than asking Tarantino which movies he'd happily watch again. Sam Peckinpah's The Wild Bunch would have sailed through that one.

Don't miss: Stephen King walked out of just one movie as an adult. It made $710 million

The six that made it

Counting Hooper's film, which Kimmel brought into the conversation, these are the six. They make an odd little festival lineup. I'd give people a decent break between the first three and the comedies.

  • The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974). Tobe Hooper takes a vanload of young people into rural Texas and gets Sally Hardesty a seat at the worst family dinner in the movies. This was the one Tarantino had already gone on record about in his book.
  • Jaws (1975). Steven Spielberg lets an entire beach town argue about a shark, then gets the three men least likely to enjoy one another's company onto the same boat. By the time Quint tells the Indianapolis story, the shark can take the scene off.
  • The Exorcist (1973). William Friedkin spends a surprising amount of time with doctors before anybody calls a priest. After what the hospital puts Regan through, the arrival of a man offering to perform an exorcism feels almost reassuring.
  • Annie Hall (1977). Woody Allen's Alvy Singer gets stuck in a movie line behind a man holding forth on Marshall McLuhan. Alvy produces the actual Marshall McLuhan to correct him. A relationship comedy that takes a minute to fulfill the fantasy of everyone who's ever stood in that line.
  • Young Frankenstein (1974). Tarantino offered Mel Brooks' comedy as a choice he could understand others making. Gene Wilder's doctor takes his creature before a distinguished audience to demonstrate a medical miracle. Naturally, they've rehearsed a tap number.
  • Back to the Future (1985). Robert Zemeckis sends Marty McFly back to 1955, where his teenage mother takes one look at him and develops exactly the wrong crush. Getting home now requires fixing his parents' first date. The DeLorean is arguably his simpler repair job.

Why The Wild Bunch doesn't make seven

Tarantino briefly put Peckinpah's 1969 western forward, then withdrew it in the same breath. Its “imperfections are part of its glory,” he explained. Take those away and you risk spoiling what he likes about the thing.

Christopher Lloyd as Doc Brown and Michael J. Fox as Marty McFly in Back to the Future (1985). Quentin Tarantino counted it among six movies he called perfect.
Christopher Lloyd as Doc Brown and Michael J. Fox as Marty McFly in Back to the Future (1985). Quentin Tarantino counted it among six movies he called perfect. Image credit: Legion Media

Which leaves Back to the Future as the only ’80s movie in the six. Marty has one shot at getting his parents to kiss, Doc has one shot at catching a bolt of lightning, and by the end you're worried about a plug coming out of a socket. Fair pick.

Previously we wrote: The Victorian Psycho movie ending: the film cuts away from the one scene the book shows in full