The Sopranos star HBO paid $3 million to keep off The Office

The Sopranos star HBO paid $3 million to keep off The Office
Image credit: Legion Media

NBC had a vacancy in Scranton. HBO had a former leading man it wanted to keep. If you believe the version Ricky Gervais heard, the difference between going to work on Monday and staying home was about a million dollars.

James Gandolfini took a meeting about replacing Steve Carell on The Office. The writers were shy. Gandolfini was shy. By one account, a roomful of people responsible for some very good television could barely get a conversation going.

Steve Schirripa, who played Bobby Baccalieri on The Sopranos, says NBC offered Gandolfini about $4 million for a season as the new boss. HBO, he says, offered $3 million for him to turn it down. On those terms, a year's work at Dunder Mifflin paid exactly a million dollars more than staying home.

What the Office writers wanted Jim to do

Carell's Michael Scott left Scranton for Colorado in season 7. The writers needed somebody who could walk into that office the next fall and make the staff behave differently. Writer-producer Danny Chun remembered the character they had in mind for Gandolfini as a warm, almost paternal boss who could turn on you in an instant. Imagine making a mistake at work and having to walk down the hall to find out which version of your dad was in today.

Gandolfini had seen episodes and liked the show. Chun, B.J. Novak and showrunner Paul Lieberstein were among the people at the meeting. The Office got close enough to discuss what kind of boss Gandolfini would be. Whether it got close enough to put a price on him depends on whose podcast you listen to.

Where the $3 million figure came from

In July 2021, Schirripa told the story on Talking Sopranos. His guest was Ricky Gervais, co-creator of the British Office, which must be an interesting way to find out what your sitcom is worth to a network that doesn't want it.

James Gandolfini as Tony Soprano and Edie Falco as Carmela in The Sopranos (1999). Steve Schirripa said HBO paid Gandolfini to pass on The Office.
James Gandolfini as Tony Soprano and Edie Falco as Carmela in The Sopranos (1999). Steve Schirripa said HBO paid Gandolfini to pass on The Office. Image credit: Legion Media

Schirripa qualified his memory of NBC's number with “I want to say.” He sounded considerably more certain about the other half of the transaction.

“HBO paid him $3 million not to do it,” Schirripa said.

Gervais wondered if HBO wanted to preserve Gandolfini's legacy as Tony Soprano. Schirripa allowed that might be part of it and pointed out that Gandolfini already had a deal with HBO. The business explanation got another airing when Jenna Fischer, who played Pam, asked her own sources what happened.

“My sources tell me that we never made a financial offer to James Gandolfini to do the show,” Fischer said on Office Ladies.

Fischer's account has Gandolfini choosing an HBO development deal and the freedom to pursue other projects. That leaves two quite different explanations for the money. A deal to develop shows for HBO is a good deal more work than collecting a check to avoid Dwight Schrute.

Don't miss: The Big Bang Theory wanted this Home Alone star so badly he had to turn it down 3 times

Back in Scranton, Andy Bernard got Michael's old job and James Spader's Robert California talked his way into the CEO's chair. The part everybody agrees on is that Tony Soprano was within one very quiet meeting of having to manage a man who grows beets.

Previously we wrote: The one thing Matthew Perry believed Friends fans would never forgive Chandler for