The Big Bang Theory wanted this Home Alone star so badly he had to turn it down 3 times

The Big Bang Theory wanted this Home Alone star so badly he had to turn it down 3 times
Image credit: Legion Media

By the third try, the producers had the actor's own manager helping them make the sale. Years later, he reckoned he'd passed up hundreds of millions of dollars. He still thought he'd made the right call.

Macaulay Culkin was the man Chuck Lorre wanted for Leonard, back when Penny didn't even live across the hall. In 2018, with Johnny Galecki about to start his twelfth season in the role, Culkin told Joe Rogan what the show had sounded like from his end of the conversation.

What they pitched him

Two astrophysics nerds share a place. A pretty girl comes to live with them. That was about the size of the pitch as Culkin remembered it, and he politely passed.

The producers came back. His second answer was a little harder to mishear.

“No, no, no. Again, flattered, but no.”

On the third approach, according to Culkin, his manager tried to talk him into it. Still no. The casting team had a reason to keep trying. Co-creator Chuck Lorre liked something slightly otherworldly about Culkin, and he'd had his eye on him before Johnny Galecki even came in.

The part was Leonard, and the girl wasn't Penny yet

Culkin left the character's name out of the Rogan interview. Casting director Ken Miller filled it in for Jessica Radloff's oral history of the show.

“Macaulay Culkin was also someone we pursued for Leonard in the first pilot.”

That last detail explains why the pitch sounds a little off to anyone who's seen even one episode. In the unaired pilot, the woman the physicists take in is Katie, played by Amanda Walsh. By the time CBS viewers met Leonard and Sheldon in 2007, Kaley Cuoco's Penny was moving in across the hall. Culkin had to make his decision before the people making The Big Bang Theory had settled on which side of the hall the girl lived on.

Don't miss: The Big Bang Theory only exists thanks to two different sitcom pitches merged into one

What three refusals cost him

Galecki got Leonard, and the show ran for 279 episodes. By 2014, Galecki, Cuoco and Jim Parsons had deals reportedly worth about $1 million apiece per episode. Looking back in 2018, Culkin reckoned he'd have made hundreds of millions of dollars if he'd said yes. That's a price he put on the job after he'd seen the paychecks. At the time, he was deciding whether to do a pilot.

The ensemble of The Big Bang Theory (2007) in the apartment. Macaulay Culkin said he turned down the sitcom three times before Johnny Galecki played Leonard.
The ensemble of The Big Bang Theory (2007) in the apartment. Macaulay Culkin said he turned down the sitcom three times before Johnny Galecki played Leonard. Image credit: Legion Media

He also told Rogan how he pictured himself spending the years between that first pilot and those million-dollar paydays. “At the same time, I’d be bashing my head against the wall.” That part of his calculation seems to have escaped his manager.

Previously we wrote: The one thing Matthew Perry believed Friends fans would never forgive Chandler for