The one thing Matthew Perry believed Friends fans would never forgive Chandler for

The one thing Matthew Perry believed Friends fans would never forgive Chandler for
Image credit: Legion Media

In season 5, the Friends writers had Chandler cheat on Monica in Las Vegas. The scene was rehearsed. Then Matthew Perry went to the writers' room.

The best relationship on Friends almost didn't survive season 5. According to actress Lisa Cash, the writers planned for Chandler to cheat on Monica in "The One in Vegas: Part 1," the 1999 two-parter that also gave us Ross and Rachel's drunk chapel wedding. Matthew Perry read it, rehearsed it, and then got it killed.

Cash was hired to play the other woman. In the original script, Chandler gets jealous after Monica has lunch with her ex, Richard (Tom Selleck), the two fight, and Cash's character, a hotel staffer, shows up at his Vegas room with room service. Chandler pours his heart out to her, and the episode was set to end with him sleeping with her.

They rehearsed it. Cash says Perry never showed a flicker of doubt on set. But on the day her scene was supposed to shoot, an assistant director told her it had been cut, along with her role:

"Matthew Perry went to the writers and said the audience would never forgive him (Chandler), which made a lot of sense."

— Lisa Cash, to NBC News

Cash wasn't fired. She stayed in the episode as a flight attendant in Ross and Rachel's scene, and she has said losing the bigger part, opposite Perry, "would have been a game changer" for her career. She still thinks Perry was right.

Why he was right

Remember where Monica and Chandler stood in 1999. The writers had originally planned their London hookup as a one-off, and only made them a couple after the studio audience went wild for them. In season 5 they were still a relationship the show was testing, not its endgame. A cheating plot would have done to them what "we were on a break" did to Ross and Rachel: given the audience a permanent asterisk.

The main cast of Friends (1994). Matthew Perry asked the writers to drop a storyline in which Chandler cheated on Monica.
The main cast of Friends (1994). Matthew Perry asked the writers to drop a storyline in which Chandler cheated on Monica. Image credit: Legion Media

Perry understood that Chandler's whole appeal was that underneath the sarcasm, he was the one guy in the group who would never do that. A Chandler who cheats out of jealousy over Richard isn't a funny, insecure guy who finally got the girl. He's a guy you can't root for anymore, and Monica's a woman you can't root for staying with him.

In the version that was cut, Chandler cheated on Monica in Vegas. In the version that aired, he married her two seasons later, and they're the only couple on Friends nobody argues about.

The actor who knew the character

This wasn't an actor protecting his image. It was an actor protecting the show. Perry knew Chandler better than anyone in that building, because, as he wrote in his memoir, a lot of Chandler was him: the jokes as armor, the terror of being left. He knew which beats the character could survive and which ones he couldn't.

Don't miss: New Friends recast imagines the sitcom made today, and Daniel Radcliffe is Chandler

Cash put it in Friends terms herself: the show already had Ross and Rachel and "we were on a break," and doing the same thing to Chandler could have changed the course of the series. Instead, Monica and Chandler became its anchor. They got the proposal, the wedding, the twins and the move to the suburbs in the finale. They got all of that because one of the actors read a script, rehearsed it, and decided his character didn't do that.

Previously we wrote: The Big Bang Theory only exists thanks to two different sitcom pitches merged into one