Black Doves repeats the Netflix mistake that makes fans quit a hit show

Black Doves repeats the Netflix mistake that makes fans quit a hit show
Image credit: Legion Media

When Black Doves came back, Helen Webb's husband had become prime minister. Quite a lot can happen between seasons when you give a man 23 months.

Netflix made the same mistake with The Diplomat. It left Hal Wyler near a car bomb in April 2023 and waited until October 2024 to tell us whether he survived. With Black Doves, Netflix already had a second season on order when the first one dropped on December 5, 2024. The next six episodes arrived on November 5, 2026. Leave a spy story on the shelf that long and even the people who loved it have a reason to pick something else tonight.

“I know I watched s01 and liked it”

Think about the question Helen carried into season 2. She's spent years selling her husband's secrets. Now he's running the country. How much has Wallace figured out about his wife? In December 2024 I'd have hit play to find out. By November 2026 I could use a reminder of what the man knew when I left him.

One viewer put it rather neatly the day after the premiere in a discussion of season 2.

“I know I watched s01 and liked it but I don't remember a thing about it 🫠”

Another viewer in the same thread watched the recap and binged all six episodes that night. The recap did its job. It also illustrates what Netflix is asking of a fan browsing after dinner. One show comes with a little homework. The next thumbnail over starts at episode one.

Seven million fewer views over the same four days

Both seasons opened on a Thursday. Both got through Sunday before Netflix closed the books on their first chart week. Season 1 got 10.8 million views in those four days. Season 2 got 3.8 million, a drop of just under 65%.

Keira Knightley as Helen and Ben Whishaw as Sam on a balcony in Black Doves (2024). Viewers waited 23 months for the two characters to return.
Keira Knightley as Helen and Ben Whishaw as Sam on a balcony in Black Doves (2024). Viewers waited 23 months for the two characters to return. Image credit: Legion Media

The second week was kinder. Here's how the two runs looked with a full Monday-to-Sunday stretch added:

  • Season 1 added 14.6 million views in week two, for a total of 25.4 million.
  • Season 2 added 6.6 million and climbed to No. 2 on Netflix's English-language TV chart, for a total of 10.4 million.

Season 2 had eleven days and couldn't quite catch what season 1 did in four. Netflix calculates views from hours watched divided by runtime. Its chart can tell us how much smaller the launch was. Anyone claiming to know how many individual fans quit for good over the wait has a much better source inside Netflix than I do.

Don't miss: Black Doves: who is the killer? Even viewers who finished the season said they couldn’t follow the ending

Netflix had already said yes

Netflix announced the renewal in August 2024, months before anyone at home had met Helen or her old friend Sam (Ben Whishaw). Creator Joe Barton told Radio Times how little of the next story existed while he was making the first one.

“We didn't have time to even consider a second series,” Barton said.

The writers tried several approaches and kept reworking the opening episode. In its opening-week analysis, What's on Netflix pointed to both the gap and “good but not great reviews.” Both could have cost the show viewers. Only one was already a problem before anybody had seen the new episodes.

One more number from Netflix's second-week chart. The old season climbed back to No. 5 with 3.7 million views. Some of those will have been newcomers. As for the returning fans, Netflix spent six episodes getting them to care whether a marriage could survive an act of espionage. Twenty-three months later, some of them were back to asking what Ben Whishaw did in this one.

Previously we wrote: Keira Knightley's Black Doves season 2 doesn't seem to be working out at all