Love Is Blind just had its worst season ever, and the reunion proved it
Jax wore her engagement ring to the Love Is Blind Boston reunion. She'd had a jeweler resize it for her pinky. That's about the most successful long-term arrangement anybody in season 11 managed to make.
Of the six engagements the show followed, five survived long enough for the trip to Mexico. One pair got married. By the November 8 reunion, Sarah Williams and John Shannon were separated, and all six couples had split. Denver ended season 9 with zero couples, too. What puts Boston at the bottom for me is what happened when its only bride finally got to tell us about married life. Sarah had barely explained why she left before a man in the audience wanted to discuss how often she went out.
Sarah had called this one before the wedding
John said he met a woman on a night out for castmate Rob Feeley's birthday, got her number and sent her inappropriate texts. He said nothing physical happened and took responsibility for the split. Sarah had a year's worth of marriage to explain, most of which took place before anybody sent a text.
“I was constantly hearing negative things about myself from the person that’s supposed to love you,” Sarah said at the reunion.
The night before her wedding, she'd FaceTimed castmates Aneha and Wilnie and told them she thought it would end with John cheating on her. That's the conversation I'd have liked to hear more about. What made her say yes the next day? Instead we heard from John's dad, who wondered why the other men weren't sticking up for his son.
Don't miss: The heartbreaking reason Love Is Blind's only Boston marriage fell apart
Then Scott, a pod cast member sitting in the audience, recalled that John had brought his Bible to breakfast and prayed with the guys before they proposed. He also had thoughts on Sarah going out with her friends. John himself had already accepted more responsibility for those texts than the men defending him seemed willing to allow.
What the reunion found time for
Nick and Vanessa Lachey had plenty to follow up on. A surprising amount of it had happened after the couples called off their engagements.
- Aneha and Cam had dinner with his family after the wedding fell through. He told her he still loved her. Two days later, on a hotel getaway they'd already booked, he told her he didn't.
- Michaella and Rob discussed his behavior around St. Patrick's Day. Rob apologized and said he'd started therapy. Much of the ensuing discussion went to beekeeper Matt, whom Michaella briefly dated afterward, and whether an “I love you” delivered on mushrooms counted.
- Jax and Stew left open the possibility of talking again. The ring made it back onto her hand. Stew made no such commitment.
Before the reunion, Netflix Life thought Boston “could make franchise history for all the wrong reasons.” Afterward, CinemaBlend's Jerrica Tisdale called the reunion “awful.” Her complaint was how little the hosts got out of the questions viewers had spent the season waiting to ask.
I can live with a season where everybody breaks up. The consolation prize is getting the couples back in one room to hear what the wedding edit missed. Boston had a bride who'd predicted her own breakup the night before she walked down the aisle. I still want to know what she and her friends said on that call. I do, however, know who brought a Bible to breakfast.
Previously we wrote: Love Is Blind's divorced couple still hang out together after cheating scandal