Sunrise on the Reaping won't show the death that made Haymitch who he is
A bicycle bell is an odd thing to take into the Hunger Games. It's also one of the smartest things Suzanne Collins put in the arena. The movie keeps the sound. Readers will notice how much has gone missing by the time they hear it.
Wellie, the twelve-year-old tribute from District 6, still dies in Sunrise on the Reaping, in theaters November 20. What the film spares us is how Haymitch finds her in the novel. What it also gives up, rather less happily, is the night he spends trying to get her home.
What Haymitch wanted for Wellie
It's the Second Quarter Quell. The Capitol has doubled the usual number of tributes to 48, and by the time Maysilee dies, Haymitch has done a great deal of losing for a boy who'll spend the next quarter century being introduced as a winner. He goes looking for Wellie. Her bell helps him find her, and he sees one decent outcome still available to him: she could be the one who gets out.
Collins lets the two spend the night hiding. Down below, Silka, the last Career tribute, is crying. Haymitch drops her a piece of sponsor chocolate. The next morning, he leaves Wellie sheltered among grapevines while he looks for firewood. When he gets back, Silka is holding the child's severed head. The girl he fed killed the girl he was trying to save.
Wellie's death doesn't make Haymitch want to win. It makes him want a Hunger Games with no winner. The Capitol has to work quite hard to sell those as the same thing.
Haymitch means to take Silka down and expects Snow to kill him. Instead, her axe rebounds off the arena's force field and the Capitol gets its victor. When we meet the adult Haymitch, his job is to send children into that system and advise them on staying alive. He already knows what it feels like to give a twelve-year-old a safe place to wait and be wrong.
What the film gives him instead
In theaters, Haymitch hears Wellie's bell after Maysilee dies and follows the sound. Silka has taken it from Wellie and is using it to draw him out. It's a cruel little trick that works in seconds, particularly if you remember what that bell meant on the page. The overnight alliance is gone.

Director Francis Lawrence explained the limit he was working with when Entertainment Weekly asked about adapting the book's violence. “The only thing we have to do in the movies is make them PG-13,” he said, citing the image of a character holding a child's head. Time was tight, too. Lawrence discussed a four-hour, twelve-minute assembly of a movie that now runs two hours and 38 minutes. That's 94 minutes of difference across the whole picture.
Don't miss: I Play Rocky takes on The Hunger Games. What's the box office prediction?
I can live without seeing what Silka has in her hand. The bit I'd put back is the chocolate. For one night Haymitch can hear the girl who's trying to kill him crying under a tree, and his first instinct is to share what he has. Imagine trying to teach that boy how to win.
Previously we wrote: The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping ending explained — how Haymitch's story leads to Katniss's father and her mockingjay pin