Dancing with the Stars is repeating the mistake that gave us Bobby Bones

Dancing with the Stars is repeating the mistake that gave us Bobby Bones
Image credit: Legion Media

Eight years ago, Dancing with the Stars sent a couple home with a semifinal scorecard worth framing. On Tuesday night the judges filled out another one. Somebody at ABC might want to keep the receipt for the frame.

Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson earned 30/30 for a paso doble and another 30 for a quickstep to the Glee version of “Valerie.” It was a tribute to Shum's late costar Naya Rivera, who sang it on the show. Six tens later, they were out. Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold got six eights and went through. This came a week after Step Up star Jenna Dewan went home.

Wood did exactly what the show asks contestants to do: give people a reason to vote for him. My quarrel is with the producers. They've already run the experiment where a perfect semifinal buys you absolutely nothing. They even spent four seasons with a rule designed to do something about it.

The Bobby Bones story starts a week before he won

The name to remember is Juan Pablo Di Pace. In the 2018 semifinals, he and Cheryl Burke danced an Argentine tango dedicated to his mother, then a salsa. ABC's scorecard that night could pass for a first draft of this week's results.

  • 2018: Di Pace and Burke, 60/60 and eliminated. Radio host Bobby Bones and Sharna Burgess, 45/60 and through.
  • 2026: Shum and Johnson, 60/60 and eliminated. Comedian Wood and Arnold, 48/60 and through.

Bones won the Mirrorball a week later. Season 28 introduced the Judges' Save. The combined scores and votes put two couples in danger, then the judges chose which one stayed. The audience still had a say in who faced elimination. The people who could tell a clean quickstep from a scruffy one got one last say before the band played anybody off.

Don't miss: Julia Stiles landed 16 out of 30 on Viral Hits Night, and the half of the scoring that can still save her never went on screen

The show dropped the save in season 32. Executive producer Deena Katz explained the decision to TVLine: “I think it should be about America.”

How twelve points disappear

Shum tied Amber Glenn for first. Wood finished last. The important wrinkle is that the show adds rankings. The judges supply one ranking, viewers supply the other, and the public vote breaks a combined tie. Host Alfonso Ribeiro clarified how a tie on the judges' board works: the next couple down drops one place even when two couples share the spot above.

Apply that to Tuesday. Shum and Glenn each get six judges' ranking points. The other four couples get five, four, three and two. Wood's twelve-point deficit on the paddles is already down to four before a single audience vote enters the calculation. We don't have the individual vote totals. We do have a perfectly good explanation for how a 48 can beat a 60.

Six times on Tuesday a judge held up a 10 for Harry Shum Jr. He could have danced both routines backwards in heels and there wasn't a single point left for them to give him.

One viewer called it “more of a popularity contest than an actual dance competition”. I'd bring back the save for eliminations and leave the trophy to the voters. Let America pick its favorite on November 24. I'd just like the guy who nailed the Glee quickstep to have had a shot at dancing for them.

Previously we wrote: Love Is Blind just had its worst season ever, and the reunion proved it