HBO's first Harry Potter scene just ruined the most magical moment of Philosopher's Stone
Of all the things I expected to argue about before HBO's Harry Potter had even aired, the availability of a second helping of potatoes was fairly low on the list. Then I went back to chapter seven. It turns out the potatoes matter.
HBO chose Harry's first start-of-term feast for the first full scene it released from the series. The Great Hall chants Dumbledore's name. John Lithgow snaps his fingers. Dinner arrives. The clip gets an awful lot done in roughly ninety seconds, including a trip up to the staff table. I wish the camera had stayed in its seat. There's an eleven-year-old down here having the first dinner of his life where he can take whatever he wants.
Why Rowling put three kinds of potatoes on the table
At Privet Drive, Dudley had a habit of eating anything Harry actually wanted, even when it made him sick. Keep that in mind when you read what Harry notices after the Sorting. There are roast potatoes, boiled potatoes and chips. There are peppermint humbugs sitting among the savory dishes. Harry helps himself to some of practically everything and leaves the peppermints.
Don't miss: Jason Isaacs confirms what we suspected all along about HBO's new Lucius Malfoy
That last bit always gets me. For once, the kid gets to be picky. Later he has treacle tart. You could lose half the menu and keep the magic, provided you let us see Harry realize that nobody's about to snatch his plate.
The special effect I wanted was a boy taking seconds without checking where his cousin was sitting.
The 2001 film understood the appeal of that table. The dishes gleam in the candlelight, Ron gets properly stuck in, and for a minute you can imagine what the room smells like. HBO's paler lighting makes it much easier to see the stretches of bare tabletop. One viewer's “Inflation hits Hogwarts” made me laugh. It's also a remarkably efficient review of a banquet that should make an audience hungry.
Meanwhile, at the grown-ups' table
The series adds an exchange Harry never hears in the book. McGonagall is pleased to have him in Gryffindor and struck by how much he resembles James. Dumbledore reminds her, “His nature is entirely his own.” I like Janet McTeer letting a little house pride show through the starch. I'd happily watch these two dissect the Sorting over a drink once the children go to bed.
Here, though, the adults get to discuss what sort of person Harry is just as we might have found out by watching him. That's what bothers me more than the washed-out color, and it's the thing a warmer filter couldn't fix. HBO has a whole season, starting December 25, to tell us what the teachers think of the Potter boy. He only gets to sit down to this dinner for the first time once.
Previously we wrote: Who is Theo in Rings of Power? The show's Mary Sue now has a secret bloodline and one of the Nine Rings