Who is Theo in Rings of Power? The show's Mary Sue now has a secret bloodline and one of the Nine Rings
I rather liked Theo when his biggest problem was explaining to his mother what he'd brought home. Three seasons in, explaining Theo to somebody who's read The Lord of the Rings is considerably harder.
Theo, played by Tyroe Muhafidin, is Bronwyn's son, a boy from the Southlands invented for The Rings of Power. In season 1, the village healer's kid found a broken sword hilt that grew a blade when it tasted his blood. In season 3, Sauron supplies a noble pedigree to go with the scar and gives him one of the Nine Rings meant for mortal Men. If you missed the bit about Theo in Tolkien, you can put the appendices down. Amazon wrote it.
A very obliging family tree
In “The Gift of Men,” Sauron makes a group of Southlanders fight over a ring. When it's down to Theo and one other man, Sauron notices the mark the hilt left on Theo's arm and kills his opponent himself. Our boy doesn't even have to win the competition once the judge recognizes him.
Then comes the family history. Sauron claims to summon Theo's dead father, Fäldred, son of Hammethreg. According to Sauron, the family served as hereditary stewards of Mordor, their powers passed from father to son, and Bronwyn killed Fäldred when she learned what he was. The dead man speaks in Black Speech. His interpreter is Sauron. Personally, I'd want a second opinion before having anything engraved.

Tolkien did write that Sauron gave nine rings to Men and that their bearers fell under his dominion. He even named one of the Nine, Khamûl the Easterling, in Unfinished Tales. He left the Witch-king's human name and parentage a mystery.
There's no Theo, no Fäldred and no hereditary stewardship of Mordor to turn up in a footnote.
The show has every inch of that blank space to play in. Why does so much of it have to belong to the kid who already found the key that set off Mount Doom?
Don't miss: Who is Rings of Power's Man with the White Flame? Aragorn's sword holds the clue
Rey from nowhere, by way of Emperor Palpatine
The Last Jedi asked Rey to live with the idea that her parents were nobodies. That was a good problem for a girl who'd spent most of her life on Jakku waiting for them to come back. Then The Rise of Skywalker made her the Emperor's granddaughter. Apparently being the girl the Skywalker lightsaber called to wasn't quite enough.
That's my Mary Sue complaint about Theo. He can be frightened, gullible and spectacularly wrong. In episode 4 he kills Arondir, the elf who loved his mother. By episode 6 he has to ask Galadriel to take the ring off his hand because he can't do it himself. Those are consequences, and the scene with Galadriel gives Muhafidin something more interesting to play than surprise at his latest inheritance.
But look at what the writers keep reserving for him. The sword that helped turn his homeland into Mordor. A family that might have ruled it. One of precisely nine rings with a place in the book's most famous verse. Even the possibility that he'll become the Witch-king has come up between Muhafidin and the showrunners, as he told Nerdist.
“It’s been discussed. I talk about it with the showrunners a lot, but they’ve got their plans that I don’t know.”
The ring is his in the show. The Witch-king's crown is still a fan theory. And I keep thinking about Bronwyn, who had a perfectly good reason to be afraid for a son who'd found something dangerous. A healer's boy helping to doom his own village was a tragedy big enough for Middle-earth. I didn't need to see his grandfather's papers.
Previously we wrote: Is The Rings of Power cancelled? Here's what happened to Amazon's five-season plan