Is Tobey Maguire in Avengers: Doomsday? Marvel left Chris Evans off the cast list too
On March 26, 2025, Marvel persuaded people to spend five hours and 27 minutes looking at the backs of chairs. I admire the nerve. I have a little less faith in the seating chart.
Tobey Maguire has no confirmed role in Avengers: Doomsday. His name was missing when Marvel rolled out the cast, which sounds fairly damning until you remember whose name was missing next to his. Chris Evans managed to sit out the entire announcement and still get a teaser practically to himself.
How Marvel hid Steve Rogers in plain sight
Here's what someone keeping diligent track of Captain America would have had in their notebook that year.
- January 2025. Asked about coming back for Doomsday, Evans told Esquire he was “happily retired.”
- March 2025. Marvel unveiled 27 cast members, including Anthony Mackie, Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellen and Robert Downey Jr. No Evans. No Maguire.
- December 2025. A man rides a motorcycle home. There's a familiar blue uniform, a baby in his arms and, in case anybody still needs a little help, the words “Steve Rogers will return in Avengers: Doomsday.”
Evans got nearly nine months of concealment out of a piece of furniture. Marvel also got a December news story it couldn't have had if it had put his name on a chair in March. Once you've seen what the studio gets out of leaving somebody off that list, an empty spot tells you very little about who's in the film.
Don't miss: Is Spider-Man in Avengers: Doomsday? Andrew Garfield swore he wasn't in No Way Home either
So what does Tobey himself have going for him?
Start with Spider-Man: No Way Home. Sam Raimi's Peter has already made the trip into the MCU and met people there. He even got one of the movie's best scenes almost entirely without dialogue. When Holland's Peter raised the Green Goblin's glider to kill Norman Osborn, Maguire's Peter caught it. He'd seen what that glider could do to Norman the first time around.

Maguire sounds easier to book than the fourteen years between Spider-Man 3 and No Way Home would suggest. In his interview for the official No Way Home movie special, he remembered his reaction to getting that call.
“I got the call and was immediately open about coming to do this.”
Give him somebody he has history with and he can do a lot with thirty seconds. The missing part is a reason to believe the Russos have actually given him those thirty seconds. Evans has footage. Maguire has a precedent. I'd keep the chair available.
Previously we wrote: Avengers: Doomsday box office prediction: can it beat Endgame with Dune opening the same day?