Netflix's No. 1 show doesn't tell you a single thing you didn't already know
By the time Netflix signed up to tell one mother's story, Tracy Pollan had already played her twice. I'd rather hear from the woman who lived it. Whether she has a mystery left to solve is another question.
Taken: Natalee Holloway debuted at No. 1 on Netflix's English-language TV chart with 12.9 million views the week of November 2–8. It's a three-part documentary about the Alabama teenager who disappeared on a graduation trip to Aruba in 2005. If you followed the case, you could have told a friend how episode three ends back in October 2023.
That's when Joran van der Sloot admitted to killing Natalee. The admission became public when he pleaded guilty in Alabama to extortion and wire fraud. He'd asked Natalee's mother, Beth, for $250,000 in exchange for the location of her daughter's remains. Those were the charges that got him into an American courtroom. The confession never produced a murder conviction in Natalee's case.
Television has been here before
Beth waited 18 years for that admission. Television found plenty to air in the meantime.
- 2009: Lifetime adapted Beth's book, Loving Natalee, as Natalee Holloway, with Pollan playing Beth.
- 2011: Pollan came back for Justice for Natalee Holloway. Even the sequel aired a dozen years before the confession.
- 2017: Oxygen's The Disappearance of Natalee Holloway followed Natalee's father, Dave, as he pursued a lead of his own.
Each of those productions had to end with a family still waiting for an answer. Netflix had the considerable advantage of knowing what the answer was before anybody sat down for an interview. As The National put it in its review, the series “does not fundamentally change what is already known about the case.”
Don't miss: Where is Natalee Holloway's killer Joran van der Sloot today?
What Beth can show you now
There is footage here you couldn't have seen on Lifetime. The filmmakers got access to recordings from the 2010 FBI operation prompted by the extortion attempt. Natalee's friends are here, too. They remember a girl nicknamed Hootie who wanted to be a doctor. You can spend years recognizing somebody's graduation picture on the news and still have no idea what her friends called her.
Beth gave a refreshingly plain answer when Netflix asked why she wanted to tell the story now.
“First and foremost, we finally had a conclusion, and that was important.”
That's the reason to watch. Beth finally gets to tell the story all the way through. If you came for a break in the case, you missed it by three years. If you came to hear Beth, this time she gets to play herself.
Previously we wrote: Concrete proof that Joran van der Sloot has been lying all along