Rings of Power's pathetic Sauron could ruin the forging of the One Ring
On November 25, Amazon finally shows the moment Tolkien fans have waited for since they first opened the books. The smith has spent three seasons looking like a guy who can't get his side project to work.
The forging of the One Ring is the reason The Rings of Power exists. It's the event every season has been crawling toward, and showrunner Patrick McKay has been promising it loudly:
"This is the season where Sauron makes the One Ring in the volcano."
— Patrick McKay, showrunner, to Empire
He also promised "a full-on villain this season." Charlie Vickers says they shot the forging over two weeks because the sequence runs so long. The final two episodes, the ones with the volcano, drop November 25.
Here's my problem. In Tolkien, the One Ring is terrifying because of who made it: Sauron poured a great part of his own power into it. A scary Ring needs a scary smith. Three seasons in, this show's smith is a punchline.
The premiere, in which the Dark Lord fails again
Season 3 opens five years after the fall of Eregion, and Sauron still can't make the master ring. In his Barad-dûr workshop he forges a golden one and won't test it himself. Instead he has an orc shove a comrade forward, and the poor test subject's hand bursts into flames, then the rest of him. Celebrimbor's skeleton hangs on the wall like a trophy, and Celebrimbor's ghost tells Sauron, "The machinery of your soul is missing a piece." His own orcs look uneasy about the whole project.

AV Club's recap explains why he's stuck: he massacred the Elven-smiths and burned their books, then discovered he needed them, which "wasn't a smart move for an aspiring Ring Lord." So he outsources the search for survivors to Marnûkh, who betrays him on the spot. One review headline diagnosed the premiere's Sauron with "a serious case of impostor syndrome."
"Isn't this guy basically Middle Earth Satan and he's chumming it up with a bunch of silly orcs."
— a commenter on r/television, on the ring-test scene
Five in-universe years after Eregion, Sauron can't make the master ring, won't test his own work, gets lectured by a ghost and loses his messenger to the enemy. That's the premiere of the season sold as his "full-on villain" era.
The defense: Sauron is the best part
The strongest counterargument comes from critics, not fans. /Film's review says season 3 "soars when Sauron's on screen ... and suffers when he isn't." TheWrap calls it the show's darkest season and the forging its highlight. Even plenty of people who've given up on everything else keep watching for Vickers.
Don't miss: Rings of Power's "angsty teen" Galadriel is closer to Tolkien than you think
All true, and it misses the point. A villain can be the most watchable thing on screen without being frightening. Vickers is great at playing a brilliant, wounded con man who sulks when things don't go his way. That's a compelling character. It's not the Dark Lord whose name makes the Wise go quiet, and the One Ring is supposed to carry the weight of the second guy, not the first.
/Film actually puts its finger on this without meaning to: it says the early episodes struggle to establish the stakes of something as abstract as the One Ring. The Ring is abstract because its menace is borrowed from its maker. If the maker reads as a frustrated craftsman, the Ring reads as a craft project.
What the forging needs
Jackson gave the forging a few seconds in the Fellowship prologue and made the Ring terrifying for nine hours of film, because everything around it, from the Black Riders to Gandalf refusing to touch it, told you who made it.
The show has three seasons of build-up and two episodes left to turn its Sauron into that guy after the fact. /Film says the moment, "for a moment, absolutely lives up to the hype." But one great moment can't undo three seasons of a Dark Lord who jokes around with orcs. If the Ring comes off the anvil on November 25 and nobody watching feels a chill, the most famous object in fantasy will have been forged by a villain the audience stopped fearing seasons ago. No final season can fix that.
Previously we wrote: Avengers: Doomsday's writing credits have the Avengers working with two wild new allies