Is Louise's death coming in Maigret? What Simenon's novels say about Maigret's wife
Short answer: Georges Simenon never killed her. In the books, Madame Maigret outlasts her husband's whole career and retires to the countryside with him. The PBS finale may have that second part in mind.
Spoilers ahead through Maigret season 2, episode 5, "The Yellow Dog, Part One."
It's easy to see why fans are nervous. Season 1 ended with Louise (Stefanie Martini) taken hostage in her own apartment by a killer Maigret had been baiting. Season 2 has been one blow after another: in "The Yellow Dog, Part One," Louise is recovering from another pregnancy loss and tells Maigret she wants a child and a life away from Paris.
Then there's the logline for Sunday's finale, "The Yellow Dog, Part Two": "The case forces Maigret and Louise to make a painful choice." Even Benjamin Wainwright admits that Maigret keeps pulling his wife's work into his cases, "which again has dangerous consequences."
So is the show building to her death? Nothing in the source material points that way, and the finale's own description talks about a choice, not a funeral.
What Simenon actually wrote about Madame Maigret
Simenon wrote more than 70 Maigret novels between 1930 and 1972, and Louise is in the background of almost all of them. Here's what the books establish:
- Who she is. Louise Léonard, from Alsace, married Jules in 1912. They lived at 132 Boulevard Richard-Lenoir for most of his career.
- What they call each other. Almost nothing. Her husband never calls her Louise, and she never calls him Jules. To readers, she's simply Madame Maigret.
- The loss. The Maigrets had one child, a daughter who died at birth. The childless couple's sadness runs through stories like "A Maigret Christmas."
- She's more than a cook. In Madame Maigret's Friend (1950), she turns detective herself and tracks down a key clue on her own.
- How it ends. In Simenon's timeline, Maigret retires at 69 to a house in Meung-sur-Loire, and Madame Maigret goes with him.
That's a remarkably stable life by crime fiction standards, where detectives' spouses often exist mainly to be put in danger.
Simenon tried to get rid of Maigret in 1934 by retiring him. In four decades, he never once tried to get rid of Madame Maigret.
The TV version has been much rougher on her, and that's where all the worry comes from.
How the PBS series changed her, and what it kept
Creator Patrick Harbinson's Louise is younger and has a career: she's a psychiatric nurse. He originally wanted to go further. "I at first wanted to make her a doctor, actually professionalize her even more so she was his equal professionally," he told the Masterpiece Studio podcast, but the Simenon estate pushed back, and he listened.

The goal of the nursing job was to flip the classic Maigret routine, so that "it's not Maigret who's coming home in the middle of the night, it's Louise." Harbinson insists that isn't a betrayal of the books:
"That very simply is being true to the Madame Maigret of the novels and setting her in 2025, 2026."
— Patrick Harbinson, creator
The pregnancy storyline comes straight from Simenon too. Harbinson remembered "a line about the heartbreak that was Louise's, Madame Maigret's life, that she'd never had a child," and asked himself the obvious question: "Oh, gosh yes, why didn't they?"
So what is the "painful choice"?
If the books are any guide, it's the countryside. In episode 5, Maurice from the Saint-Fiacre estate, where Maigret grew up, tells Louise he wishes Maigret would come home and run the estate like his father did. Louise wants out of Paris. Simenon's Maigrets end up in a house in the provinces. The pieces fit.
Don't miss: Miss Scarlet and the Duke season 7 release date: the final season is set, and Ivy won't be in it
Wainwright frames it as the season's big question:
"It's kind of the question of the series. Will he stay or will he go?"
— Benjamin Wainwright, Maigret
He adds that Maigret has "this nagging sense in the background that he could have a simpler, possibly a happier life elsewhere," and wonders whether city life is keeping the couple from having a baby. Martini says the same thing from Louise's side: "She's searching for somewhere where she can be a mother."
In other words, the real threat in Sunday's finale isn't that Maigret loses Louise. It's that Paris loses Maigret.
Of course, this is an adaptation that already put Louise in a hostage situation the books never did, so nobody can promise she'll make it through untouched. But killing her would cut against everything Simenon wrote and everything Harbinson says he's protecting. Simenon cared enough about the character to have strong opinions on who played her, once declaring the Madame Maigret on Japanese television the best of them all, "even including the French ones."
The man who wrote that wasn't planning to bury her, and the people adapting him don't seem to be either.
Previously we wrote: Mistletoe Murders: who is the killer in every mystery, from the chess coach to the walk-in freezer