Prince William's favorite Netflix spy show doesn't seem to be working out at all

Prince William's favorite Netflix spy show doesn't seem to be working out at all
Image credit: Legion Media

The Prince and Princess of Wales spent Christmas 2024 bingeing Black Doves. Two years later, season 2 opened at roughly a third of season 1's audience.

Black Doves season 2 arrived on Netflix on Thursday, November 5, and opened with 3.8 million views and 19.9 million hours for the week of November 2–8. Season 1 opened with 10.8 million. That's a drop of about 65 percent, and it isn't a quirk of the calendar: season 1 also premiered on a Thursday, in December 2024, so both seasons got the same four-day opening window. Season 2 finished fourth on Netflix's English TV list, behind a Natalee Holloway docuseries, a Matthew Perry documentary in its second week, and the third season of Nobody Wants This.

That's a rough landing for a show with a royal endorsement.

The royal binge

In December 2024, at a Christmas party for the 1st Battalion Mercian Regiment in Wiltshire, Prince William told families what he'd been watching at home. As the Telegraph reported, he and the Princess of Wales had been working through Netflix together, including Black Doves. It was the perfect royal holiday pick: a Keira Knightley spy thriller set in London at Christmas, with Ben Whishaw as a sardonic assassin and Sarah Lancashire as the spymaster nobody crosses.

The rest of the country agreed. Season 1 spent six weeks in Netflix's global top 10, logged 248.8 million hours and 45.3 million views, and charted in all 92 Netflix regions. Its second week jumped 35 percent to 14.6 million views and made it the most-watched English-language series on the platform. Netflix had renewed it in August 2024, before season 1 had even premiered, which surprised creator Joe Barton enough that he joked most of his shows get canceled almost instantly.

Season 1 opened to 10.8 million views and a royal endorsement. Season 2 opened to 3.8 million on the same four-day clock.

What went wrong

The two-year gap did this. Season 2's opening ranks 13th of 14 comparable thriller launches, and it isn't because the show got worse. The critics actually liked season 2 more: Rotten Tomatoes had it at 94 percent from 18 reviews two days after launch, and Metacritic gave it 83, up from season 1's 78. Pajiba called it "the most enjoyable binge in ages."

Keira Knightley and Ben Whishaw in Black Doves (2024). Season 1 logged 45.3 million views and charted in all 92 Netflix regions
Keira Knightley and Ben Whishaw in Black Doves (2024). Season 1 logged 45.3 million views and charted in all 92 Netflix regions. Image credit: Legion Media

That leaves timing. Season 1 was a Christmas show that arrived at Christmas. Season 2, which Barton says isn't tied to the holiday, dropped on Bonfire Night. It's a sequel to a cozy-and-murderous December binge, released in early November with no snow, after two years in which the audience moved on to other spies. In the UK, at least, the show is holding up: season 2 was the second-most-watched series there in its opening week, and the most-searched series on the UK streaming chart on November 8.

Netflix hasn't announced a third season, and on these numbers I wouldn't bet on one.

Don't miss: Keira Knightley's Black Doves season 2 doesn't seem to be working out at all

The royal watchlist

If it helps Barton sleep, the Waleses don't usually pick losers. Here's what the royal family has admitted to watching over the years:

  • Prince William: watched all of Killing Eve, according to its producer, and talked about its dark humor. He's a devoted Blackadder fan, and did a sketch with Stephen Fry in 2020. He also says he watches Zulu every year before Christmas.
  • William and Kate together: Homeland and Game of Thrones. "We're both actually quite keen on box sets," William told the BBC in 2017, and he once told a radio DJ she should "definitely watch Game of Thrones."
  • The Princess of Wales: a Strictly Come Dancing devotee, like her mother, Carole Middleton. She took Princess Charlotte and Prince Louis to visit the set.
  • King Charles: a fan of Poldark, and he praised Emmerdale on its 50th anniversary at the National Television Awards.
  • Queen Camilla: admitted to watching Bridgerton and, with the King, Wolf Hall.
  • Prince Harry: watches Jeopardy with Meghan, and has confessed to Love Island.
  • Queen Elizabeth II: reportedly loved Downton Abbey.

Killing Eve ran four seasons. Game of Thrones ran eight. Strictly is still going. A royal fan is not a curse. But being the show the future King binged one Christmas doesn't guarantee anything two years later, when the audience has to remember why it cared.

Previously we wrote: Rings of Power season 3 proves a mediocre show can't survive a two-year wait